"This preparatory sort of idealism is the one that, as I just suggested, Berkeley made prominent, and, after a fashion familiar. I must state it in my own way, although one in vain seeks to attain novelty in illustrating so frequently described a view"
About this Quote
Royce opens with the kind of throat-clearing humility that is actually a power move. By calling the view a "preparatory sort of idealism", he signals that we are not yet at the main event; we are in the antechamber of a bigger system. The phrase subtly lowers the stakes of what follows, not because it is trivial, but because it is foundational - a scaffold the reader must climb before Royce can ask for commitment to his own metaphysical architecture.
Invoking Berkeley does double duty. It situates Royce inside a recognizable lineage (British idealism's most famous provocateur) while also hinting that Berkeley's version has been domesticated: "after a fashion familiar". That little clause carries a historian's skepticism. Berkeley is no longer scandal; he's curriculum. Royce is telling you: you've heard this tune before, and the culture has already smoothed its rough edges.
Then comes the real subtext: "I must state it in my own way". Royce doesn't pretend to invent idealism; he claims the right to reframe it. Philosophical originality, he implies, rarely arrives as a new doctrine. It arrives as a new arrangement of emphases, a different set of consequences drawn out of old premises. The final admission - that novelty is vain when the view is "so frequently described" - reads as both intellectual honesty and strategic inoculation. He preempts the cheap critique ("this is just Berkeley") while quietly asserting that the decisive question isn't whether the idea is new, but whether his articulation prepares you for what he plans to build on it.
Invoking Berkeley does double duty. It situates Royce inside a recognizable lineage (British idealism's most famous provocateur) while also hinting that Berkeley's version has been domesticated: "after a fashion familiar". That little clause carries a historian's skepticism. Berkeley is no longer scandal; he's curriculum. Royce is telling you: you've heard this tune before, and the culture has already smoothed its rough edges.
Then comes the real subtext: "I must state it in my own way". Royce doesn't pretend to invent idealism; he claims the right to reframe it. Philosophical originality, he implies, rarely arrives as a new doctrine. It arrives as a new arrangement of emphases, a different set of consequences drawn out of old premises. The final admission - that novelty is vain when the view is "so frequently described" - reads as both intellectual honesty and strategic inoculation. He preempts the cheap critique ("this is just Berkeley") while quietly asserting that the decisive question isn't whether the idea is new, but whether his articulation prepares you for what he plans to build on it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Josiah
Add to List





