"This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before"
About this Quote
Bernstein’s line is protest phrased as practice: not a threat, not a slogan, but a vow to double down on craft. The brilliance is the pivot from the language of retaliation to the language of rehearsal. “Reply” normally cues an escalation; he swaps bullets for bars, suggesting that the real counterforce to violence isn’t moral posturing but an alternative way of being human, performed in public, night after night.
The intent is pointedly civic. Bernstein isn’t claiming music can magically “solve” brutality; he’s insisting that culture is a site of resistance precisely because it trains attention, discipline, and empathy - the very muscles violence atrophies. “More intensely” rejects numbness. “More beautifully” refuses the aesthetic of despair. “More devotedly” frames art as duty, not luxury, and subtly shames any temptation to retreat into silence or cynicism.
Context matters: this is Bernstein, a conductor-composer who treated the concert hall as a public square and who lived through war, political paranoia, and the 1960s’ eruptions of American conflict. The quote is often associated with his response to the assassination of John F. Kennedy, when a planned performance became a kind of national wake. In that moment, “making music” wasn’t escapism; it was collective breathing, a way to keep a society from being defined by its worst day.
The subtext is stubborn optimism with steel in it: if violence wants to shrink our world to fear, Bernstein answers by enlarging it - audibly.
The intent is pointedly civic. Bernstein isn’t claiming music can magically “solve” brutality; he’s insisting that culture is a site of resistance precisely because it trains attention, discipline, and empathy - the very muscles violence atrophies. “More intensely” rejects numbness. “More beautifully” refuses the aesthetic of despair. “More devotedly” frames art as duty, not luxury, and subtly shames any temptation to retreat into silence or cynicism.
Context matters: this is Bernstein, a conductor-composer who treated the concert hall as a public square and who lived through war, political paranoia, and the 1960s’ eruptions of American conflict. The quote is often associated with his response to the assassination of John F. Kennedy, when a planned performance became a kind of national wake. In that moment, “making music” wasn’t escapism; it was collective breathing, a way to keep a society from being defined by its worst day.
The subtext is stubborn optimism with steel in it: if violence wants to shrink our world to fear, Bernstein answers by enlarging it - audibly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|---|
| Source | Leonard Bernstein — quotation: "This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before." — cited on Wikiquote (Leonard Bernstein page). |
More Quotes by Leonard
Add to List









