"Those churches have closed down or have been merged with a church that has a more positive vision"
About this Quote
A “more positive vision” is doing a lot of work here. Hybels isn’t just describing administrative housekeeping; he’s framing ecclesial contraction as a moral sorting mechanism. Churches didn’t simply fail, age out, or lose members in a secularizing culture. They “closed down” or “merged” because they lacked the right affective posture. The line smuggles in a managerial theology: what survives is what markets hope well.
The intent is pastoral and strategic at once. Hybels, the famed architect of seeker-sensitive megachurch culture, speaks in the language of momentum, optics, and forward motion. “Positive” isn’t only an emotional adjective; it’s a branding promise. It implies a church that looks outward, emphasizes possibility over guilt, and offers a streamlined, accessible experience. That’s a real corrective to communities that can calcify into insularity or perpetual grievance.
The subtext, though, is sharper: decline becomes a referendum on attitude. If you’re struggling, perhaps your vision was insufficiently “positive.” That’s both comforting (there’s a fix) and quietly punitive (your closure is evidence of spiritual mismanagement). It also avoids naming the hard variables - demographics, finances, scandal, theological conflict - by translating complexity into vibe.
Context matters. In late-20th and early-21st-century American Christianity, “vision” became the favored currency of leadership, replacing older talk of doctrine or tradition with a CEO-ish emphasis on mission statements and measurable outcomes. Hybels’ phrasing fits that era: optimism as ecclesial survival strategy, consolidation as progress, and a subtle warning that negativity isn’t merely unattractive - it’s unsustainable.
The intent is pastoral and strategic at once. Hybels, the famed architect of seeker-sensitive megachurch culture, speaks in the language of momentum, optics, and forward motion. “Positive” isn’t only an emotional adjective; it’s a branding promise. It implies a church that looks outward, emphasizes possibility over guilt, and offers a streamlined, accessible experience. That’s a real corrective to communities that can calcify into insularity or perpetual grievance.
The subtext, though, is sharper: decline becomes a referendum on attitude. If you’re struggling, perhaps your vision was insufficiently “positive.” That’s both comforting (there’s a fix) and quietly punitive (your closure is evidence of spiritual mismanagement). It also avoids naming the hard variables - demographics, finances, scandal, theological conflict - by translating complexity into vibe.
Context matters. In late-20th and early-21st-century American Christianity, “vision” became the favored currency of leadership, replacing older talk of doctrine or tradition with a CEO-ish emphasis on mission statements and measurable outcomes. Hybels’ phrasing fits that era: optimism as ecclesial survival strategy, consolidation as progress, and a subtle warning that negativity isn’t merely unattractive - it’s unsustainable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Bill
Add to List

