"Thousand got away to other countries; thousands returned to Spain tempted by false promises of kindness. By the tens of thousands, these Spaniards died of neglect in the concentration camps"
About this Quote
Gellhorn writes with the cold arithmetic of catastrophe, because sentiment would be a lie. The sentence moves in brutal escalations - “thousand,” “thousands,” “tens of thousands” - a numeric drumbeat that mimics how mass death becomes administratively manageable and morally invisible. It’s journalism as indictment: she isn’t describing tragedy as an accident of war, she’s naming it as a system with inputs and outputs, a pipeline that ends in camps.
The pivot is “tempted by false promises of kindness.” That phrase weaponizes the language of mercy. “Kindness” is not merely absent; it’s counterfeited, offered as bait to flush refugees back into the state’s reach. Gellhorn’s intent is to deny the regime the comfort of ambiguity. People didn’t “return” in the neutral sense; they were lured, misled, made to bet their lives on a manufactured benevolence. The cruelty is doubled: first the deception, then the neglect that kills without needing a firing squad.
Context matters: Gellhorn covered the Spanish Civil War and its aftermath, when Franco’s victory turned political opponents and displaced civilians into a disposable category. “Concentration camps” lands with particular force here, not as metaphor but as an accusation of modern governance: the state corrals bodies, starves them, lets time do the murdering. The subtext is aimed at outsiders too - governments and readers who prefer clean narratives of “peace restored.” Gellhorn refuses closure. The war may end on paper; the machinery of punishment keeps running.
The pivot is “tempted by false promises of kindness.” That phrase weaponizes the language of mercy. “Kindness” is not merely absent; it’s counterfeited, offered as bait to flush refugees back into the state’s reach. Gellhorn’s intent is to deny the regime the comfort of ambiguity. People didn’t “return” in the neutral sense; they were lured, misled, made to bet their lives on a manufactured benevolence. The cruelty is doubled: first the deception, then the neglect that kills without needing a firing squad.
Context matters: Gellhorn covered the Spanish Civil War and its aftermath, when Franco’s victory turned political opponents and displaced civilians into a disposable category. “Concentration camps” lands with particular force here, not as metaphor but as an accusation of modern governance: the state corrals bodies, starves them, lets time do the murdering. The subtext is aimed at outsiders too - governments and readers who prefer clean narratives of “peace restored.” Gellhorn refuses closure. The war may end on paper; the machinery of punishment keeps running.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Martha
Add to List
