"Three-quarters of the sicknesses of intelligent people come from their intelligence. They need at least a doctor who can understand this sickness"
About this Quote
Proust slips a scalpel under the bourgeois faith in “intelligence” as pure advantage and shows the inflammation underneath. The line isn’t an anti-intellectual shrug; it’s a diagnosis of a particular class of suffering: the kind produced by overperception. To be intelligent, in Proust’s world, is to be cursed with too much signal. You notice micro-shifts in tone, status, desire; you replay them; you build theories; you anticipate losses before they arrive. The mind becomes a hyperactive immune system, attacking ordinary life as if it were a threat.
The “three-quarters” is doing sly rhetorical work. It sounds empirical, almost medical, but it’s really comic precision: an exaggeration that borrows the authority of measurement to make a psychological point. Proust is also protecting his claim from melodrama. Not all suffering comes from intelligence, he concedes; just enough to indict it as a major cause.
Then he pivots to the doctor: not a mechanic for the body, but an interpreter for the mind’s self-made ailments. The subtext is a critique of medicine’s blind spot - its impatience with illnesses that are entangled with meaning, memory, and interpretation. In early 20th-century France, as modern psychology was emerging and neurasthenia was a fashionable label, Proust positions the “intelligent” patient as someone whose symptoms are partly linguistic: they need a clinician who can read them.
It’s also self-portraiture. Proust’s own asthmatic, hypersensitive life becomes an argument: the artist’s acuity is both instrument and injury, and only a doctor who respects that paradox can treat it.
The “three-quarters” is doing sly rhetorical work. It sounds empirical, almost medical, but it’s really comic precision: an exaggeration that borrows the authority of measurement to make a psychological point. Proust is also protecting his claim from melodrama. Not all suffering comes from intelligence, he concedes; just enough to indict it as a major cause.
Then he pivots to the doctor: not a mechanic for the body, but an interpreter for the mind’s self-made ailments. The subtext is a critique of medicine’s blind spot - its impatience with illnesses that are entangled with meaning, memory, and interpretation. In early 20th-century France, as modern psychology was emerging and neurasthenia was a fashionable label, Proust positions the “intelligent” patient as someone whose symptoms are partly linguistic: they need a clinician who can read them.
It’s also self-portraiture. Proust’s own asthmatic, hypersensitive life becomes an argument: the artist’s acuity is both instrument and injury, and only a doctor who respects that paradox can treat it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mental Health |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Marcel
Add to List









