"To appreciate the noble is a gain which can never be torn from us"
About this Quote
Goethe is selling a kind of inner wealth that can’t be repossessed: the trained ability to recognize nobility when you meet it. Not nobility as a title, but as a quality of character, action, or art. The line works because it quietly shifts the stakes from having noble things to having a noble lens. You can lose money, status, even the people you admire; what remains is the cultivated capacity to see what’s worth admiring in the first place.
The intent is moral but not preachy. Goethe isn’t ordering you to be good; he’s arguing that admiration is a durable asset. That’s subversive in cultures where “being impressed” gets treated as weakness or naïveté. Here, appreciation is strength: it refines desire, sets standards, and immunizes you against the cheap seductions of the merely flashy. “Can never be torn from us” carries the pressure of political and personal instability, a reminder that external life is vulnerable to confiscation, exile, illness, fashion. Interior formation isn’t.
Context matters: Goethe wrote through revolutions, Napoleonic upheavals, and the transition from Enlightenment confidence to Romantic inwardness. His work is obsessed with Bildung, self-cultivation as a life project. This sentence is Bildung distilled: the real “gain” isn’t the noble object but the permanent enlargement of the self that comes from encountering it properly. Even if the world turns coarse, the person who has learned to recognize the noble can’t unlearn that knowledge. They carry a standard inside them, which is precisely what makes it untouchable.
The intent is moral but not preachy. Goethe isn’t ordering you to be good; he’s arguing that admiration is a durable asset. That’s subversive in cultures where “being impressed” gets treated as weakness or naïveté. Here, appreciation is strength: it refines desire, sets standards, and immunizes you against the cheap seductions of the merely flashy. “Can never be torn from us” carries the pressure of political and personal instability, a reminder that external life is vulnerable to confiscation, exile, illness, fashion. Interior formation isn’t.
Context matters: Goethe wrote through revolutions, Napoleonic upheavals, and the transition from Enlightenment confidence to Romantic inwardness. His work is obsessed with Bildung, self-cultivation as a life project. This sentence is Bildung distilled: the real “gain” isn’t the noble object but the permanent enlargement of the self that comes from encountering it properly. Even if the world turns coarse, the person who has learned to recognize the noble can’t unlearn that knowledge. They carry a standard inside them, which is precisely what makes it untouchable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Johann
Add to List













