"To be a clergyman, and all that is compassionate and virtuous, ought to be the same thing"
About this Quote
Richardson is quietly dragging the church by holding it to its own sales pitch. In a single, poised sentence, he turns “clergyman” from a job title into a moral claim, then refuses to let the institution wriggle out of the implications. The key word is “ought”: it admits the gap between ideal and reality while insisting that the gap is a scandal, not an acceptable compromise. He’s not praising clerics; he’s setting a trap for them.
The line also works because it fuses role and character. “Clergyman” isn’t treated as someone who performs rituals or manages a parish; it’s treated as a synonym for “compassionate and virtuous.” That’s rhetorical pressure, not description. If the public grants clergy social authority, Richardson argues, it must be because they embody the virtues they preach. If they don’t, their authority becomes mere costume.
Context matters: Richardson’s fiction is steeped in moral psychology and the everyday consequences of reputation, power, and hypocrisy. In an 18th-century Britain where the Church of England was entangled with class, patronage, and social discipline, the clerical collar could function as both spiritual sign and social shield. Richardson’s sentence strips away that shield. It implies that religious office without compassion is not just personal failure; it’s institutional fraud. The moral bar isn’t heroism. It’s basic decency, made non-negotiable by the very act of claiming the pulpit.
The line also works because it fuses role and character. “Clergyman” isn’t treated as someone who performs rituals or manages a parish; it’s treated as a synonym for “compassionate and virtuous.” That’s rhetorical pressure, not description. If the public grants clergy social authority, Richardson argues, it must be because they embody the virtues they preach. If they don’t, their authority becomes mere costume.
Context matters: Richardson’s fiction is steeped in moral psychology and the everyday consequences of reputation, power, and hypocrisy. In an 18th-century Britain where the Church of England was entangled with class, patronage, and social discipline, the clerical collar could function as both spiritual sign and social shield. Richardson’s sentence strips away that shield. It implies that religious office without compassion is not just personal failure; it’s institutional fraud. The moral bar isn’t heroism. It’s basic decency, made non-negotiable by the very act of claiming the pulpit.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List






