"To be able to live and work in the United States is a privilege"
About this Quote
“To be able to live and work in the United States is a privilege” is the kind of sentence that sounds humble until you notice what it’s doing: it frames belonging as conditional, not inherent. Coming from David Geffen, a self-made entertainment mogul who rose in an industry built on access, gatekeeping, and networks, “privilege” reads less like gratitude than like a worldview. It’s the language of someone who has benefited from American mobility and wants that story to function as a moral lesson.
The intent is stabilizing: to cast the U.S. not as a flawed polity with obligations to residents and workers, but as a scarce opportunity bestowed on the deserving. That wording subtly shifts power away from rights and toward permission. It asks you to feel thankful before you ask questions. It’s also a reputational move, aligning an ultra-wealthy figure with civic virtue and immigrant-adjacent aspiration without having to wade into policy specifics.
The subtext is disciplinary. If life here is a “privilege,” then dissent can be recoded as ingratitude, labor demands as entitlement, and immigrants’ claims as negotiable. This is especially potent in moments of cultural backlash or economic anxiety, when elites often reach for patriotism as a solvent for inequality.
Context matters: Geffen’s career tracks the postwar American promise of reinvention, amplified by globalization and the winner-take-most economy. In that light, the quote isn’t just about America. It’s about maintaining a system where access is precious, and those who’ve made it can present their success as proof that the rules are fair.
The intent is stabilizing: to cast the U.S. not as a flawed polity with obligations to residents and workers, but as a scarce opportunity bestowed on the deserving. That wording subtly shifts power away from rights and toward permission. It asks you to feel thankful before you ask questions. It’s also a reputational move, aligning an ultra-wealthy figure with civic virtue and immigrant-adjacent aspiration without having to wade into policy specifics.
The subtext is disciplinary. If life here is a “privilege,” then dissent can be recoded as ingratitude, labor demands as entitlement, and immigrants’ claims as negotiable. This is especially potent in moments of cultural backlash or economic anxiety, when elites often reach for patriotism as a solvent for inequality.
Context matters: Geffen’s career tracks the postwar American promise of reinvention, amplified by globalization and the winner-take-most economy. In that light, the quote isn’t just about America. It’s about maintaining a system where access is precious, and those who’ve made it can present their success as proof that the rules are fair.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List




