"To denigrate the union movement in this way is to denigrate the right and the ability of people who are not rich to organize and to accomplish things together"
About this Quote
Beatty’s line works less like a policy argument than a rebuke of cultural snobbery. He’s not debating union contracts in the fine print; he’s calling out the reflex that treats collective bargaining as suspect the moment it’s practiced by people without wealth. The phrasing “in this way” matters: it suggests the attack on unions isn’t just disagreement, it’s a rhetorical posture - a sneer that frames organized labor as greedy, outdated, or corrupt while leaving the organizing habits of the rich (lobbyists, trade groups, boardrooms, political donors) conveniently unexamined.
The quote’s engine is repetition: “denigrate... denigrate.” It’s a hammering moral equivalence. If you mock unions, you’re not merely criticizing an institution; you’re insulting the basic democratic skill of ordinary people pooling leverage. Beatty widens “union movement” into something more elemental: “the right and the ability... to accomplish things together.” That move shifts the frame from wages to dignity, from economics to citizenship.
Contextually, it lands in a Hollywood-adjacent world where “union” can mean SAG, writers, crew - the hidden infrastructure behind glamour. Beatty, an insider with outsized cultural capital, uses that privilege to point at a class double standard: individualism is celebrated as virtue when it’s a rich person’s myth, but cooperation becomes a vice when it’s a working person’s tool. The subtext is blunt: if you weaken unions, you weaken the only scalable counterweight most people have.
The quote’s engine is repetition: “denigrate... denigrate.” It’s a hammering moral equivalence. If you mock unions, you’re not merely criticizing an institution; you’re insulting the basic democratic skill of ordinary people pooling leverage. Beatty widens “union movement” into something more elemental: “the right and the ability... to accomplish things together.” That move shifts the frame from wages to dignity, from economics to citizenship.
Contextually, it lands in a Hollywood-adjacent world where “union” can mean SAG, writers, crew - the hidden infrastructure behind glamour. Beatty, an insider with outsized cultural capital, uses that privilege to point at a class double standard: individualism is celebrated as virtue when it’s a rich person’s myth, but cooperation becomes a vice when it’s a working person’s tool. The subtext is blunt: if you weaken unions, you weaken the only scalable counterweight most people have.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Warren
Add to List
