"To govern is always to choose among disadvantages"
About this Quote
Governing, de Gaulle suggests, isn’t the noble art of perfect solutions; it’s the bruising craft of selecting the least damaging option and then owning the fallout. The line works because it strips politics of its sentimental alibis. No “win-win,” no clean moral geometry - just trade-offs, scarcity, and consequences. In eight words, he reframes leadership as triage.
The specific intent is defensive and clarifying at once. De Gaulle is inoculating the idea of authority against purity tests: if every available path carries costs, then condemnation is easy and responsibility is rare. The subtext: a leader should be judged less by the ability to avoid harm than by the courage to prioritize harms transparently, under pressure, and in full view. It’s also a subtle rebuke to armchair critics and ideological maximalists, who can afford to demand immaculate outcomes because they don’t have to sign the orders.
Context matters. De Gaulle’s career ran through national collapse, liberation, colonial unwinding, and the turbulent birth of France’s Fifth Republic. He navigated the Algerian War, a crisis designed to poison every choice: preserve empire and deepen violence, or concede independence and risk civil rupture. His rhetoric often traded in grandeur; this sentence is unusually austere, almost clinical, which gives it authority. It sounds like a man who has watched institutions buckle and understands that legitimacy is built not on perfection, but on hard choices made without illusion.
The specific intent is defensive and clarifying at once. De Gaulle is inoculating the idea of authority against purity tests: if every available path carries costs, then condemnation is easy and responsibility is rare. The subtext: a leader should be judged less by the ability to avoid harm than by the courage to prioritize harms transparently, under pressure, and in full view. It’s also a subtle rebuke to armchair critics and ideological maximalists, who can afford to demand immaculate outcomes because they don’t have to sign the orders.
Context matters. De Gaulle’s career ran through national collapse, liberation, colonial unwinding, and the turbulent birth of France’s Fifth Republic. He navigated the Algerian War, a crisis designed to poison every choice: preserve empire and deepen violence, or concede independence and risk civil rupture. His rhetoric often traded in grandeur; this sentence is unusually austere, almost clinical, which gives it authority. It sounds like a man who has watched institutions buckle and understands that legitimacy is built not on perfection, but on hard choices made without illusion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List








