"To rest satisfied with existing evils, as if we could do nothing, is not obedience; but neither is it obedience to imitate the actions of the apostles"
About this Quote
Darby’s line is a theological jab disguised as a pastoral warning: don’t confuse spiritual “obedience” with either complacency or cosplay. The first target is quietism - the pious shrug that treats social and ecclesial dysfunction as fate. “Existing evils” aren’t merely unfortunate; they’re a test of moral clarity. If you say you can do nothing, Darby implies, you’ve already chosen a side: the side of inertia dressed up as humility.
Then he turns the blade on the opposite temptation: religious reenactment. “Neither is it obedience to imitate the actions of the apostles” lands as an anti-nostalgia manifesto. Darby, a key architect of the Plymouth Brethren movement, distrusted the way institutional Christianity legitimated itself by appealing to apostolic precedent. His point isn’t that the apostles were wrong; it’s that copying their moves like a script mistakes historical contingency for divine command. Apostolic acts happened in a particular moment of revelation, crisis, and founding authority. Treating them as a timeless template is another way of dodging discernment in the present.
The subtext is classic Darby: a suspicion of church tradition, a priority on scripture and conscience, and a demand for action that isn’t merely activism or antiquarianism. “Obedience” here becomes something harder: responsiveness. Not passive acceptance of rot, not performative primitivism, but a lived attentiveness to what faith requires now - even if that means breaking with both the comfort of the status quo and the romance of the early church.
Then he turns the blade on the opposite temptation: religious reenactment. “Neither is it obedience to imitate the actions of the apostles” lands as an anti-nostalgia manifesto. Darby, a key architect of the Plymouth Brethren movement, distrusted the way institutional Christianity legitimated itself by appealing to apostolic precedent. His point isn’t that the apostles were wrong; it’s that copying their moves like a script mistakes historical contingency for divine command. Apostolic acts happened in a particular moment of revelation, crisis, and founding authority. Treating them as a timeless template is another way of dodging discernment in the present.
The subtext is classic Darby: a suspicion of church tradition, a priority on scripture and conscience, and a demand for action that isn’t merely activism or antiquarianism. “Obedience” here becomes something harder: responsiveness. Not passive acceptance of rot, not performative primitivism, but a lived attentiveness to what faith requires now - even if that means breaking with both the comfort of the status quo and the romance of the early church.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List








