"To study history means submitting to chaos and nevertheless retaining faith in order and meaning"
About this Quote
History, for Hesse, isn’t a tidy ledger of causes and effects; it’s an endurance test for the mind’s appetite for pattern. “Submitting to chaos” lands like a dare: if you really look at the record - wars misfired by ego, revolutions swallowed by bureaucracy, ordinary lives erased by accident - you have to concede that human events are often incoherent in the moment and only retrospectively stitched into narratives. The verb “submitting” is key. It’s not “acknowledging” or “noticing” chaos. It’s surrendering your preferred storylines and letting the mess of contingency have its say.
Then comes the counterweight: “nevertheless retaining faith in order and meaning.” Hesse isn’t promising that history contains an inherent moral arc; he’s describing a discipline, almost a spiritual posture. Faith, here, is an act of will, not a conclusion drawn from evidence. The subtext is that without that chosen faith, historical study curdles into cynicism or nihilism - the belief that power is the only plot and cruelty the only constant. With it, you can face catastrophe without reducing everything to catastrophe.
Context matters: Hesse lived through the collapse of old European certainties, the First World War, the rise of fascism, the Second World War. A novelist steeped in inner life and moral awakening, he’s suggesting that the historian’s task resembles the artist’s: to stare at the disorder honestly while resisting the cheap comforts of either fatalism or propaganda. Meaning isn’t found by denying chaos; it’s built by thinking through it.
Then comes the counterweight: “nevertheless retaining faith in order and meaning.” Hesse isn’t promising that history contains an inherent moral arc; he’s describing a discipline, almost a spiritual posture. Faith, here, is an act of will, not a conclusion drawn from evidence. The subtext is that without that chosen faith, historical study curdles into cynicism or nihilism - the belief that power is the only plot and cruelty the only constant. With it, you can face catastrophe without reducing everything to catastrophe.
Context matters: Hesse lived through the collapse of old European certainties, the First World War, the rise of fascism, the Second World War. A novelist steeped in inner life and moral awakening, he’s suggesting that the historian’s task resembles the artist’s: to stare at the disorder honestly while resisting the cheap comforts of either fatalism or propaganda. Meaning isn’t found by denying chaos; it’s built by thinking through it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Hermann
Add to List








