"To surrender to ignorance and call it God has always been premature, and it remains premature today"
About this Quote
Asimov lands the punch with a scientist’s impatience for intellectual shortcuts: “God” here isn’t attacked as a private faith so much as a public alibi. The target is a familiar maneuver in human history, where the boundary of current knowledge gets fenced off as sacred territory. His verb choice matters. “Surrender” casts the move not as humble awe but as capitulation, a decision to stop asking. “Call it God” suggests labeling, even branding: a name slapped onto uncertainty to make it feel resolved.
The line works because it frames ignorance as a moving frontier. What once looked like divine machinery - disease, lightning, the motion of planets - shrank under the pressure of explanation. So the subtext is almost Darwinian: if you keep placing God in the gaps, the gaps keep closing, and the concept gets reduced to whatever science hasn’t reached yet. “Premature” is the clinical word that makes the critique sting. It implies not only that the conclusion is wrong, but that it violates process, like publishing before the data are in.
Context sharpens the intent. Asimov wrote from inside a 20th-century moment when science became both savior and scapegoat: antibiotics and атом bombs, spaceflight and Cold War dread. His skepticism isn’t airy philosophy; it’s a warning about cultural habits. When a society treats mystery as permission to stop thinking, it doesn’t just misunderstand the universe - it underinvests in curiosity, education, and the slow, unglamorous work of finding out.
The line works because it frames ignorance as a moving frontier. What once looked like divine machinery - disease, lightning, the motion of planets - shrank under the pressure of explanation. So the subtext is almost Darwinian: if you keep placing God in the gaps, the gaps keep closing, and the concept gets reduced to whatever science hasn’t reached yet. “Premature” is the clinical word that makes the critique sting. It implies not only that the conclusion is wrong, but that it violates process, like publishing before the data are in.
Context sharpens the intent. Asimov wrote from inside a 20th-century moment when science became both savior and scapegoat: antibiotics and атом bombs, spaceflight and Cold War dread. His skepticism isn’t airy philosophy; it’s a warning about cultural habits. When a society treats mystery as permission to stop thinking, it doesn’t just misunderstand the universe - it underinvests in curiosity, education, and the slow, unglamorous work of finding out.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Isaac
Add to List








