"To the old, the new is usually bad news"
About this Quote
“To the old, the new is usually bad news” lands with Hoffer’s trademark severity: a single line that indicts not just age, but the psychology of status. He’s not making a sentimental point about generational misunderstanding. He’s describing a defensive reflex. The “new” isn’t merely unfamiliar; it’s a threat to whatever the old have accumulated and arranged into a stable story about themselves - competence, authority, moral certainty, even relevance. If your identity is built out of hard-won habits, novelty reads like an accusation: you’ve been doing it wrong, or at least no longer matter.
Hoffer’s intent is almost diagnostic. The phrase “usually” is doing important work, implying he’s watched this pattern repeat across movements, workplaces, and nations. The line also smuggles in a political warning: when people who hold power experience change as humiliation, they don’t argue about policy, they fight to preserve dignity. “Bad news” is the language of crisis, not debate. It suggests that for the old, modernity arrives as a headline about loss.
Context matters: Hoffer wrote as a longshoreman-philosopher in a 20th century defined by mass politics, propaganda, and rapid technological churn. In that world, the past wasn’t simply quaint; it was a platform for control. The subtext is bracingly unsentimental: resistance to change is often less about wisdom and more about fear - fear that the new will reveal how contingent the old order always was.
Hoffer’s intent is almost diagnostic. The phrase “usually” is doing important work, implying he’s watched this pattern repeat across movements, workplaces, and nations. The line also smuggles in a political warning: when people who hold power experience change as humiliation, they don’t argue about policy, they fight to preserve dignity. “Bad news” is the language of crisis, not debate. It suggests that for the old, modernity arrives as a headline about loss.
Context matters: Hoffer wrote as a longshoreman-philosopher in a 20th century defined by mass politics, propaganda, and rapid technological churn. In that world, the past wasn’t simply quaint; it was a platform for control. The subtext is bracingly unsentimental: resistance to change is often less about wisdom and more about fear - fear that the new will reveal how contingent the old order always was.
Quote Details
| Topic | Change |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List









