"To understand Mozart's contradictory qualities would indeed be to understand genius"
About this Quote
Genius, Foss implies, isn’t a clean line you can diagram; it’s a knot you have to feel in your hands. Mozart is the perfect exhibit because his music keeps refusing the personality profiles we try to pin on it. The same composer can write something that seems to grin at you with salon-ready elegance, then pivot to a passage that opens into dread, tenderness, or outright cosmic mischief. Foss’s “contradictory qualities” points to that unnerving coexistence: play and profundity, craft and spontaneity, sweetness and menace, formal balance and sudden emotional asymmetry.
The intent is partly defensive, partly provocative. As a 20th-century composer who lived through modernism’s battles over “seriousness,” Foss is pushing back against the idea that greatness must be consistent, stern, or stylistically “pure.” Mozart’s contradictions aren’t flaws to reconcile; they’re the operating system. If you can hold those opposites without reducing them to a narrative (“child prodigy,” “troubled genius,” “perfect classicist”), you’re closer to understanding how art can be both engineered and alive.
Subtext: our cultural craving for coherence is the enemy of real listening. We want Mozart to be either divine clockwork or effortless inspiration, either aristocratic refinement or relatable human mess. Foss insists it’s the simultaneity that matters. Mozart’s genius is not that he chose one register, but that he could let multiple truths speak at once, sometimes in the same bar, and make the contradictions sound inevitable.
The intent is partly defensive, partly provocative. As a 20th-century composer who lived through modernism’s battles over “seriousness,” Foss is pushing back against the idea that greatness must be consistent, stern, or stylistically “pure.” Mozart’s contradictions aren’t flaws to reconcile; they’re the operating system. If you can hold those opposites without reducing them to a narrative (“child prodigy,” “troubled genius,” “perfect classicist”), you’re closer to understanding how art can be both engineered and alive.
Subtext: our cultural craving for coherence is the enemy of real listening. We want Mozart to be either divine clockwork or effortless inspiration, either aristocratic refinement or relatable human mess. Foss insists it’s the simultaneity that matters. Mozart’s genius is not that he chose one register, but that he could let multiple truths speak at once, sometimes in the same bar, and make the contradictions sound inevitable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Lukas
Add to List
