"Today it is not big business that we have to fear. It is big government"
About this Quote
The line flips a familiar villain and dares the listener to update their paranoia. Phillips, an abolitionist who spent his life distrusting entrenched power, isn’t offering a neat pro-business slogan so much as a warning about where coercion actually concentrates. “Today” is the operative word: it frames fear as something historically contingent, not an eternal ideology. Whatever yesterday’s threat was, Phillips implies, the modern danger has migrated into the machinery that can legislate, police, tax, conscript, and launder force through procedure.
The subtext is sharper than a generic anti-state sentiment. Phillips is betting that people understand “big business” as visible, grasping, and self-interested; it can be boycotted, outcompeted, shamed. “Big government” is harder: it speaks in the neutral voice of public good, wraps itself in legality, and turns dissent into disorder. That’s why the fear is different. It’s not that corruption exists, but that it can be sanctified.
Context matters because Phillips came out of fights where law was a weapon. The Fugitive Slave Act and the broader apparatus protecting slavery showed how the state can become the most efficient enforcement arm for private exploitation. His sentence carries the bitterness of someone who watched “order” used to return human beings to bondage, and watched courts and legislatures call it justice.
Rhetorically, the quote is built like a pivot: a calm dismissal (“not big business”) followed by a blunt replacement (“big government”). It works because it collapses the comfort of a single enemy and forces a harder question: who gets to wield legitimate force when “the public” is invoked?
The subtext is sharper than a generic anti-state sentiment. Phillips is betting that people understand “big business” as visible, grasping, and self-interested; it can be boycotted, outcompeted, shamed. “Big government” is harder: it speaks in the neutral voice of public good, wraps itself in legality, and turns dissent into disorder. That’s why the fear is different. It’s not that corruption exists, but that it can be sanctified.
Context matters because Phillips came out of fights where law was a weapon. The Fugitive Slave Act and the broader apparatus protecting slavery showed how the state can become the most efficient enforcement arm for private exploitation. His sentence carries the bitterness of someone who watched “order” used to return human beings to bondage, and watched courts and legislatures call it justice.
Rhetorically, the quote is built like a pivot: a calm dismissal (“not big business”) followed by a blunt replacement (“big government”). It works because it collapses the comfort of a single enemy and forces a harder question: who gets to wield legitimate force when “the public” is invoked?
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Wendell
Add to List







