"Today the tyrant rules not by club or fist, but disguised as a market researcher, he shepherds his flocks in the ways of utility and comfort"
About this Quote
McLuhan’s tyrant doesn’t kick down doors; he hands you a clipboard and asks what you “prefer.” The line lands because it flips the classic image of oppression into something blandly professional: the market researcher as soft-power cop. That disguise is the point. When coercion is routed through “utility and comfort,” domination becomes hard to spot, harder to resist, and easiest to rationalize. Who argues with convenience?
The subtext is McLuhan’s signature suspicion that modern media and consumer systems don’t just deliver choices, they manufacture the conditions under which choices feel natural. “Shepherds his flocks” is deliberately pastoral, almost biblical, and it’s doing double work: the public becomes a managed herd, and management gets recoded as care. The tyrant’s authority isn’t brute force but guidance, nudging, optimization. In McLuhan’s world, the medium is the governance: environments shape behavior more effectively than orders do.
Context matters. Writing in the mid-20th century, McLuhan watched advertising, television, polling, and behavioral research turn public life into an instrument panel. The postwar boom promised liberation through products; the Cold War promised safety through systems. He hears a new kind of authoritarianism in that promise: power that doesn’t demand obedience, it elicits participation. You fill out the survey. You click. You “choose.” The club is obsolete when people can be steered by the metrics of comfort, and when conformity arrives as personalized service.
The subtext is McLuhan’s signature suspicion that modern media and consumer systems don’t just deliver choices, they manufacture the conditions under which choices feel natural. “Shepherds his flocks” is deliberately pastoral, almost biblical, and it’s doing double work: the public becomes a managed herd, and management gets recoded as care. The tyrant’s authority isn’t brute force but guidance, nudging, optimization. In McLuhan’s world, the medium is the governance: environments shape behavior more effectively than orders do.
Context matters. Writing in the mid-20th century, McLuhan watched advertising, television, polling, and behavioral research turn public life into an instrument panel. The postwar boom promised liberation through products; the Cold War promised safety through systems. He hears a new kind of authoritarianism in that promise: power that doesn’t demand obedience, it elicits participation. You fill out the survey. You click. You “choose.” The club is obsolete when people can be steered by the metrics of comfort, and when conformity arrives as personalized service.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Marshall
Add to List










