"Today we voted as Democrats and Republicans. Tomorrow we begin again as New Yorkers"
About this Quote
A clean pivot like this is politics at its most necessary: take the heat of partisan combat, then insist the room rejoin the same civic body. Clinton’s line works because it treats party identity as temporary and local identity as permanent. “Today” and “tomorrow” compress a messy democratic process into a simple emotional arc: contest, then continuity. It’s an antidote to the hangover of elections, when winning feels like ownership and losing feels like exile.
The subtext is both generous and strategic. “We voted as Democrats and Republicans” acknowledges division without dramatizing it; the verb “voted” narrows conflict to a legitimate act rather than an existential war. Then “we begin again” frames politics as maintenance, not apocalypse. The phrase carries a quiet civic theology: citizenship is a habit you recommit to daily, not a jersey you wear only on Election Day.
“New Yorkers” does the real rhetorical heavy lifting. It’s not just a location; it’s a brand of toughness, solidarity, and shared vulnerability (especially post-9/11, when New York unity became a national script). Clinton is tapping that mythology to create a higher-order identity that can absorb disagreement. She’s also positioning herself as a custodian of the city’s self-image: pragmatic, resilient, too busy to stay mad.
Contextually, this kind of line is built for the moment after a vote, when legitimacy must be re-stitched. It doesn’t ask anyone to change their mind; it asks them to change their posture. That’s why it lands.
The subtext is both generous and strategic. “We voted as Democrats and Republicans” acknowledges division without dramatizing it; the verb “voted” narrows conflict to a legitimate act rather than an existential war. Then “we begin again” frames politics as maintenance, not apocalypse. The phrase carries a quiet civic theology: citizenship is a habit you recommit to daily, not a jersey you wear only on Election Day.
“New Yorkers” does the real rhetorical heavy lifting. It’s not just a location; it’s a brand of toughness, solidarity, and shared vulnerability (especially post-9/11, when New York unity became a national script). Clinton is tapping that mythology to create a higher-order identity that can absorb disagreement. She’s also positioning herself as a custodian of the city’s self-image: pragmatic, resilient, too busy to stay mad.
Contextually, this kind of line is built for the moment after a vote, when legitimacy must be re-stitched. It doesn’t ask anyone to change their mind; it asks them to change their posture. That’s why it lands.
Quote Details
| Topic | New Beginnings |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Hillary
Add to List


