"Truth always originates in a minority of one, and every custom begins as a broken precedent"
About this Quote
Durant is flattering the lone dissenter, but he is also warning you about how brutally history laundered yesterday's heresy into today's etiquette. "Minority of one" is a deliberately prickly phrase: it turns the language of democracy against itself. Majority rule is supposed to legitimize truth; Durant implies the opposite. Real insight often arrives as an irritant, carried by a single person stubborn enough to withstand the crowd's need for social peace.
The second clause sharpens the blade. "Every custom begins as a broken precedent" reframes tradition as an act of rebellion with good PR. Custom pretends to be ancient, natural, inevitable. Durant reminds us it is usually someone's earlier refusal to obey - a breach that proved useful, persuasive, or simply survivable, then got repeated until it felt like "the way we do things". It's an historian's demystification trick: take what looks like permanence and show the scuff marks where it started.
Context matters: Durant spent his career narrating civilizations as evolving systems, not moral fairy tales. This line fits a 20th-century liberal humanist confronting mass politics, propaganda, and the anxiety of conformity. The subtext isn't "trust every contrarian". It's closer to: progress is structurally inconvenient. Societies don't upgrade by committee; they absorb shock, then normalize it. If you want to recognize truth in real time, don't ask whether it's popular. Ask whether it's costly to say, and whether the speaker can bear the loneliness that comes with being early.
The second clause sharpens the blade. "Every custom begins as a broken precedent" reframes tradition as an act of rebellion with good PR. Custom pretends to be ancient, natural, inevitable. Durant reminds us it is usually someone's earlier refusal to obey - a breach that proved useful, persuasive, or simply survivable, then got repeated until it felt like "the way we do things". It's an historian's demystification trick: take what looks like permanence and show the scuff marks where it started.
Context matters: Durant spent his career narrating civilizations as evolving systems, not moral fairy tales. This line fits a 20th-century liberal humanist confronting mass politics, propaganda, and the anxiety of conformity. The subtext isn't "trust every contrarian". It's closer to: progress is structurally inconvenient. Societies don't upgrade by committee; they absorb shock, then normalize it. If you want to recognize truth in real time, don't ask whether it's popular. Ask whether it's costly to say, and whether the speaker can bear the loneliness that comes with being early.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Will
Add to List









