"Truth is simply a compliment paid to sentences seen to be paying their way"
About this Quote
Rorty turns "truth" into a social currency, and the provocation lands because it deflates a word most philosophers treat like a sacred object. Calling truth "a compliment paid to sentences" shifts the focus from reality itself to the community that rewards certain descriptions of reality. The phrase "paying their way" is the needle: sentences aren’t true because they mirror the world; they’re true because they earn their keep - they help us predict, coordinate, justify, build, and survive.
The subtext is anti-heroic. Rorty is taking aim at the long philosophical hunt for foundations: the idea that, beneath our arguments, there must be a final, non-negotiable bedrock called Truth. His pragmatist lineage (James, Dewey) shows in the insistence on consequences over correspondence. What matters is not whether language hooks onto the world with metaphysical Velcro, but whether our vocabularies are useful tools for coping with it.
Context matters because this is late-20th-century philosophy, post-positivist and post-Quine: suspicion toward the fantasy of a neutral "view from nowhere", and a renewed attention to language as the medium of thought rather than its transparent wrapper. The intent isn’t to license lying or reduce facts to opinion; it’s to demote "truth" from an oracle to an accolade. Rorty’s wager is that this demotion makes us less dogmatic and more inventive - more willing to revise our sentences when they stop paying their way.
The subtext is anti-heroic. Rorty is taking aim at the long philosophical hunt for foundations: the idea that, beneath our arguments, there must be a final, non-negotiable bedrock called Truth. His pragmatist lineage (James, Dewey) shows in the insistence on consequences over correspondence. What matters is not whether language hooks onto the world with metaphysical Velcro, but whether our vocabularies are useful tools for coping with it.
Context matters because this is late-20th-century philosophy, post-positivist and post-Quine: suspicion toward the fantasy of a neutral "view from nowhere", and a renewed attention to language as the medium of thought rather than its transparent wrapper. The intent isn’t to license lying or reduce facts to opinion; it’s to demote "truth" from an oracle to an accolade. Rorty’s wager is that this demotion makes us less dogmatic and more inventive - more willing to revise our sentences when they stop paying their way.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List





