"Truth is tough. It will not break, like a bubble, at a touch; nay, you may kick it about all day like a football, and it will be round and full at evening"
About this Quote
Holmes makes truth feel less like a fragile heirloom and more like playground equipment: scuffed, booted, and still stubbornly intact. The image does two sly things at once. First, it punctures the melodrama that often surrounds “truth” as something easily “shattered.” A bubble pops at the slightest pressure; a football is designed for impact. By choosing the football, Holmes implies that what we call truth doesn’t need constant protection from disagreement, mockery, or even bad-faith handling. If it’s real, it survives contact.
Second, the metaphor carries a provocation. “You may kick it about all day” isn’t just a compliment to truth’s durability; it’s a backhanded portrait of society’s habits. People don’t merely discover truth - they rough it up, treat it as a contest object, use it to score points. Holmes anticipates a modern media ecosystem where facts get punted between factions. His wager is that the day’s abuse won’t deform the thing itself, only our relation to it.
Context matters: Holmes Sr. lived through the mid-19th century’s convulsions, when American public life tested whether reality could hold under ideological strain. As a poet (and a public intellectual adjacent to the Brahmin class), he’s defending a liberal faith in sturdiness: truth may be delayed, distorted, temporarily buried under noise, but it isn’t “broken” by argument. The subtext is reassurance with edge: stop acting like truth is delicate - and stop pretending your kicks count as refutation.
Second, the metaphor carries a provocation. “You may kick it about all day” isn’t just a compliment to truth’s durability; it’s a backhanded portrait of society’s habits. People don’t merely discover truth - they rough it up, treat it as a contest object, use it to score points. Holmes anticipates a modern media ecosystem where facts get punted between factions. His wager is that the day’s abuse won’t deform the thing itself, only our relation to it.
Context matters: Holmes Sr. lived through the mid-19th century’s convulsions, when American public life tested whether reality could hold under ideological strain. As a poet (and a public intellectual adjacent to the Brahmin class), he’s defending a liberal faith in sturdiness: truth may be delayed, distorted, temporarily buried under noise, but it isn’t “broken” by argument. The subtext is reassurance with edge: stop acting like truth is delicate - and stop pretending your kicks count as refutation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr., The Autocrat of the Breakfast-Table (1858). Contains the line commonly cited as: "Truth is tough... you may kick it about all day like a football..." |
More Quotes by Oliver
Add to List










