"Truth never was indebted to a lie"
About this Quote
Young’s line swings a moral hammer with the confidence of someone who thinks the argument is already over. “Truth never was indebted to a lie” isn’t just piety; it’s a shot at a convenient modern instinct (modern to him, too): that a little fabrication can serve a higher good. He refuses the “noble lie” premise outright. Truth, in this view, doesn’t need counterfeit currency. If you have to smuggle your point in under cover of falsehood, the point is already compromised.
The sentence works because it weaponizes bookkeeping language. “Indebted” turns ethics into accounting: debts accrue, interest compounds, ledgers remember. A lie isn’t merely a mistake, it’s a liability that attaches itself to whatever cause it supposedly helps. Young implies that even when deception produces a desirable outcome, it quietly taxes the outcome’s legitimacy. You get the result, but you lose the authority to claim you deserved it.
Context matters: Young writes in a Protestant, Enlightenment-adjacent Britain where sincerity is becoming a public virtue and religious moralism is still culturally muscular. As a poet of “Night Thoughts,” he’s obsessed with mortality, judgment, and the soul’s long-term balance sheet. That’s the subtext: lies feel practical because they solve short-term problems; truth answers to longer horizons. Young isn’t naive about persuasion. He’s drawing a bright line to shame rhetorical tricks, political expediency, and social hypocrisy by insisting that truth is self-sufficient, and that any alliance with falsehood is a confession of weakness, not strategy.
The sentence works because it weaponizes bookkeeping language. “Indebted” turns ethics into accounting: debts accrue, interest compounds, ledgers remember. A lie isn’t merely a mistake, it’s a liability that attaches itself to whatever cause it supposedly helps. Young implies that even when deception produces a desirable outcome, it quietly taxes the outcome’s legitimacy. You get the result, but you lose the authority to claim you deserved it.
Context matters: Young writes in a Protestant, Enlightenment-adjacent Britain where sincerity is becoming a public virtue and religious moralism is still culturally muscular. As a poet of “Night Thoughts,” he’s obsessed with mortality, judgment, and the soul’s long-term balance sheet. That’s the subtext: lies feel practical because they solve short-term problems; truth answers to longer horizons. Young isn’t naive about persuasion. He’s drawing a bright line to shame rhetorical tricks, political expediency, and social hypocrisy by insisting that truth is self-sufficient, and that any alliance with falsehood is a confession of weakness, not strategy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
