"Uncertainty and fear and ignorance about immigrants, about people who are different, has a history as old as our Nation"
About this Quote
Uncertainty, fear, ignorance: Gutierrez stacks the nouns like a prosecutor laying evidence on a table, then links them to immigrants with the blunt moral math of cause and effect. The line isn’t trying to win a policy seminar. It’s trying to expose a reflex. By pairing “immigrants” with the broader category “people who are different,” he quietly argues that immigration panic is rarely just about visas or wages; it’s about belonging, hierarchy, and who gets to be seen as fully American.
The killer move is the time scale. “As old as our Nation” folds today’s headlines into a familiar national pattern: Know-Nothing nativism, Chinese Exclusion, the quotas of the 1920s, Japanese American internment, the post-9/11 suspicion of Muslims, the border politics of the 2010s. He’s not claiming novelty for the moment; he’s denying it. That’s a strategic reframing: if the fear is ancient, it’s less credible as “common sense” and more recognizable as recurring scapegoat politics.
There’s subtext in the pronoun too. “Our Nation” invites listeners to choose a side: either you inherit the country’s ideals, or you inherit its anxieties. Gutierrez, long identified with immigration reform and Latino representation, uses history as a mirror and a warning. The intent is to make anti-immigrant sentiment feel smaller than it pretends to be: not a brave defense of culture, but an old American habit of mistaking difference for danger.
The killer move is the time scale. “As old as our Nation” folds today’s headlines into a familiar national pattern: Know-Nothing nativism, Chinese Exclusion, the quotas of the 1920s, Japanese American internment, the post-9/11 suspicion of Muslims, the border politics of the 2010s. He’s not claiming novelty for the moment; he’s denying it. That’s a strategic reframing: if the fear is ancient, it’s less credible as “common sense” and more recognizable as recurring scapegoat politics.
There’s subtext in the pronoun too. “Our Nation” invites listeners to choose a side: either you inherit the country’s ideals, or you inherit its anxieties. Gutierrez, long identified with immigration reform and Latino representation, uses history as a mirror and a warning. The intent is to make anti-immigrant sentiment feel smaller than it pretends to be: not a brave defense of culture, but an old American habit of mistaking difference for danger.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Luis
Add to List


