"Unfortunately, what many people forget is that judges are just lawyers in robes"
About this Quote
The line lands like a pin to the balloon of judicial mystique. Tammy Bruce is puncturing the civic bedtime story that judges float above the messiness of ordinary politics and personal interest. “Unfortunately” does a lot of work: it frames the revelation as a disappointment, as if we ought to have a priestly class on the bench but are stuck with something more pedestrian. Then comes the demotion. “Just lawyers” is a deliberately leveling phrase, pulling judges back into the professional tribe they came from: trained advocates, steeped in procedural combat, rewarded for winning arguments. “In robes” is the kicker, treating the costume as theater - the sartorial trick that converts a career in persuasion into an aura of impartial authority.
The specific intent is clarifying and suspicious at once. It doesn’t argue that judges are corrupt; it argues that they’re human, culturally formed, and institutionally incentivized. The subtext is a warning against naive deference: if judges are products of the legal class, then their decisions will reflect that class’s assumptions about order, rights, punishment, and power. It’s also an argument about legitimacy: if we keep pretending courts are above ideology, we’re easier to shock - and to manipulate - when rulings align with predictable worldviews.
Contextually, the quote fits a modern American moment when confirmation battles, blockbuster Supreme Court decisions, and viral “activist judge” rhetoric have trained the public to read jurisprudence as politics by other means. Bruce’s jab tries to reframe reverence as a liability: robes don’t erase biography; they just formalize it.
The specific intent is clarifying and suspicious at once. It doesn’t argue that judges are corrupt; it argues that they’re human, culturally formed, and institutionally incentivized. The subtext is a warning against naive deference: if judges are products of the legal class, then their decisions will reflect that class’s assumptions about order, rights, punishment, and power. It’s also an argument about legitimacy: if we keep pretending courts are above ideology, we’re easier to shock - and to manipulate - when rulings align with predictable worldviews.
Contextually, the quote fits a modern American moment when confirmation battles, blockbuster Supreme Court decisions, and viral “activist judge” rhetoric have trained the public to read jurisprudence as politics by other means. Bruce’s jab tries to reframe reverence as a liability: robes don’t erase biography; they just formalize it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Tammy
Add to List
