"Unity in things Necessary, Liberty in things Unnecessary, and Charity in all"
About this Quote
A Puritan clergyman doesn’t reach for “liberty” and “charity” as soft, Hallmark virtues; Baxter deploys them as governance. The line is a piece of ecclesial statecraft from a century when English Christianity was splintering into factions that didn’t just disagree, but prosecuted, exiled, and occasionally killed over doctrine. In that context, “Unity in things Necessary” reads less like a plea for harmony and more like a triage protocol: decide what counts as essential, bind the community to it, and stop bleeding out over secondary quarrels.
The subtext is strategic humility. Baxter implicitly admits that religious people are prone to smuggling personal preference into the category of “Necessary” and baptizing it as truth. By carving out “things Unnecessary,” he offers a pressure valve: a sanctioned space for difference that doesn’t threaten the core. It’s an argument for institutional resilience, not individual self-expression.
Then he lands on “Charity in all,” a word that, in Baxter’s register, means disciplined love: interpret others generously, restrain righteous cruelty, refuse to make disagreement a license for contempt. That final clause also functions as a check on the first two. Unity can become coercion; liberty can become indifference. Charity is the ethic that keeps unity from hardening into authoritarianism and liberty from dissolving into fragmentation.
The elegance is in the hierarchy: a community survives by ranking commitments, but it stays moral by how it treats people while doing the ranking.
The subtext is strategic humility. Baxter implicitly admits that religious people are prone to smuggling personal preference into the category of “Necessary” and baptizing it as truth. By carving out “things Unnecessary,” he offers a pressure valve: a sanctioned space for difference that doesn’t threaten the core. It’s an argument for institutional resilience, not individual self-expression.
Then he lands on “Charity in all,” a word that, in Baxter’s register, means disciplined love: interpret others generously, restrain righteous cruelty, refuse to make disagreement a license for contempt. That final clause also functions as a check on the first two. Unity can become coercion; liberty can become indifference. Charity is the ethic that keeps unity from hardening into authoritarianism and liberty from dissolving into fragmentation.
The elegance is in the hierarchy: a community survives by ranking commitments, but it stays moral by how it treats people while doing the ranking.
Quote Details
| Topic | Kindness |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List







