Daily Inspiration Quote by Stephen Gardiner

"Victorian architecture in the United States was copied straight from England"

Stephen Gardiner, Architect

About this Quote

The barb in Gardiner's line is its blunt refusal to flatter American originality. "Copied straight" isn’t neutral description; it’s an accusation in plain clothes, aimed at a national habit of turning import into inheritance and then pretending it was destiny. Coming from an architect, the charge carries an insider’s impatience: he’s not just noting stylistic influence, he’s calling out a professional culture that treated prestige as something you could ship across the Atlantic in pattern books.

The phrase also needles the romance people attach to "Victorian" as a cozy, homegrown aesthetic. Gardiner re-centers it as an export product: gables, turrets, and gingerbread as packaged signals of respectability, purchased along with the social script they implied. In that reading, the copying is less about laziness than aspiration. The young United States, fast rich and socially anxious, borrowed England’s architectural vocabulary to borrow England’s authority - to make new money look like old lineage.

Context matters: nineteenth-century American builders did rely heavily on British precedents, and the spread of illustrated manuals made replication easy and profitable. Still, Gardiner’s absolutism ("straight") is strategic. It compresses a messy history - regional adaptations, local materials, hybridization - into a provocation designed to puncture nostalgia and force a harder question: when Americans built "Victorian" streetscapes, were they building homes, or performing legitimacy?

Quote Details

Topic	Art
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Stephen Add to List

About the Author

United Kingdom Flag

Stephen Gardiner (April 25, 1924 - February 15, 2007) was a Architect from United Kingdom.

36 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"From the early days of European migration to America, in the 17th Century, the prototype of buildings was based on English precedent, even if mostly translated into the locally available material in abundance: timber"

Harry Seidler, Architect

Harry Seidler

"The bungalow had more to do with how Americans live today than any other building that has gone remotely by the name of architecture in our history"

Russell Lynes, Critic

"If I could create an ideal world, it would be an England with the fire of the Elizabethans, the correct taste of the Georgians, and the refinement and pure ideals of the Victorians"

H. P. Lovecraft, Novelist

"Then years back, when I moved to California, I happened to see a book about fashions of 19th-century Victorian England, only four pages of which was devoted to the dress of the working class"

Martin C. Smith, Writer

"The American order reveals a method that was largely the outcome of material necessity, as exemplified by the Colonial style and the grid"

Stephen Gardiner, Architect

"Revived in this country the long forgotten beauties of Gothic architecture"

James Wyatt, Architect

"The only legitimate artists in England are the architects"

Benjamin Haydon, Artist

"The history of the Victorian Age will never be written: we know too much about it"

Lytton Strachey, Critic

"When a finished work of 20th century sculpture is placed in an 18th century garden, it is absorbed by the ideal representation of the past, thus reinforcing political and social values that are no longer with us"

Robert Smithson, Artist

"I want to lead the Victorian life, surrounded by exquisite clutter"

Freddie Mercury, Musician

Freddie Mercury

"Builders eventually took advantage of the look of modernism to build cheaply and carelessly"

Arthur Erickson, Architect

Arthur Erickson

"No architect troubled to design houses that suited people who were to live in them, because that would have meant building a whole range of different houses. It was far cheaper and, above all, timesaving to make them identical"

Michael Ende, Writer

"In the United States there has been a kind of a structure in the Modern art world. The New York School was nearly a coherent thing-for a minute"

Howard Hodgkin, Artist

"What has happened to architecture since the second world war that the only passers-by who can contemplate it without pain are those equipped with a white stick and a dog?"

Bernard Levin, Journalist

"But after the time there I'd had it with fashion again, so I left to go to architecture school in a summer course at Harvard, which didn't last very long"

Stephen Sprouse, Designer

"In other words, each piece of the building must look as though it was designed for that particular building"

Minoru Yamasaki, Architect

"I went to England in the '70s, and I was in my early 20s. There was still a residue of that era of being an underclass or colonial. I assume it must have been a more aggressive and prominent attitude 40 years before that, because Australia internationally wasn't regarded as having much cultural value. We were a country full of sheep and convicts"

Geoffrey Rush, Actor

"British fashion is self confident and fearless. It refuses to bow to commerce, thus generating a constant flow of new ideas whilst drawing in British heritage"

Alexander McQueen, Designer

Alexander McQueen

"I probably spent the first 20 years of my life wanting to be as American as possible. Through my 20s, and into my 30s, I began to become aware of how so much of my art and architecture has a decidedly Eastern character"

Maya Lin, Architect

"Among those best known, their highest ambition is to build American homes, possess American furniture, dress in American clothes, adopt the American style of living and be American citizens"

Sheldon Jackson, Politician