"Violence commands both literature and life, and violence is always crude and distorted"
About this Quote
Violence, Glasgow suggests, is an attention economy: it seizes the narrative whether you want it to or not. Her phrasing is almost accusatory toward the reader and the writer alike. “Commands” isn’t neutral; it implies a coercive power that overrides subtler human motives. In fiction, violence can hijack craft, turning character into casualty and nuance into spectacle. In life, it does the same thing socially: it simplifies messy histories into blunt, headline-ready morality plays.
The second clause is the corrective, and it’s where Glasgow’s aesthetic and ethical suspicion shows. Violence is “always crude and distorted” not because it’s rare or unbelievable, but because it warps perception. It reduces people to types (victim, villain, hero), compresses time into before-and-after, and makes complex causes feel like single triggers. That distortion is precisely why it “commands”: it offers the false clarity of shock.
Context matters. Glasgow wrote through Reconstruction’s long shadow, World War I, and the mechanization of cruelty that made old romantic narratives of honor look obscene. As a Southern novelist often read against the grain of genteel mythmaking, she knew how societies launder brutality into tradition, and how novels can either participate in that laundering or expose it. The line reads like a warning to storytellers: if you reach for violence to give your work “weight,” you may be borrowing force at the cost of truth. It will grab the reader, yes, but it will also bend everything around it.
The second clause is the corrective, and it’s where Glasgow’s aesthetic and ethical suspicion shows. Violence is “always crude and distorted” not because it’s rare or unbelievable, but because it warps perception. It reduces people to types (victim, villain, hero), compresses time into before-and-after, and makes complex causes feel like single triggers. That distortion is precisely why it “commands”: it offers the false clarity of shock.
Context matters. Glasgow wrote through Reconstruction’s long shadow, World War I, and the mechanization of cruelty that made old romantic narratives of honor look obscene. As a Southern novelist often read against the grain of genteel mythmaking, she knew how societies launder brutality into tradition, and how novels can either participate in that laundering or expose it. The line reads like a warning to storytellers: if you reach for violence to give your work “weight,” you may be borrowing force at the cost of truth. It will grab the reader, yes, but it will also bend everything around it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ellen
Add to List




