"War is cruelty. There is no use trying to reform it. The crueler it is, the sooner it will be over"
About this Quote
Sherman doesn’t romanticize war; he strips it down to an operating principle. “War is cruelty” is less a lament than a premise, and the next sentence slams the door on the comforting fantasy that violence can be made tidy, ethical, or politely contained. He’s not arguing that cruelty is good. He’s arguing that pretending war can be humane is how nations drift into drawn-out slaughter with clean consciences.
The provocation sits in the logic of acceleration: “The crueler it is, the sooner it will be over.” This is the doctrine of compression, an early articulation of what later strategists would call shock and awe. Sherman’s intent is practical and political: if you want peace, you don’t dabble; you apply overwhelming force to collapse the enemy’s capacity and will to continue. The subtext is aimed at civilians and moral critics as much as at soldiers: if you choose war, you are choosing brutality, and the half-measures you demand to feel righteous will simply extend the suffering.
Context matters. Sherman is speaking from the furnace of the American Civil War, after years of attrition and in the lead-up to (and justification for) “hard war” campaigns like the March to the Sea, designed to break the Confederacy’s logistics and morale. It’s a brutal clarity that doubles as moral blackmail: accept the ugliness now, or pay for your scruples in additional graves. The line endures because it weaponizes realism against sentimentality, forcing readers to confront the price of “limited” war when the underlying aim is unconditional victory.
The provocation sits in the logic of acceleration: “The crueler it is, the sooner it will be over.” This is the doctrine of compression, an early articulation of what later strategists would call shock and awe. Sherman’s intent is practical and political: if you want peace, you don’t dabble; you apply overwhelming force to collapse the enemy’s capacity and will to continue. The subtext is aimed at civilians and moral critics as much as at soldiers: if you choose war, you are choosing brutality, and the half-measures you demand to feel righteous will simply extend the suffering.
Context matters. Sherman is speaking from the furnace of the American Civil War, after years of attrition and in the lead-up to (and justification for) “hard war” campaigns like the March to the Sea, designed to break the Confederacy’s logistics and morale. It’s a brutal clarity that doubles as moral blackmail: accept the ugliness now, or pay for your scruples in additional graves. The line endures because it weaponizes realism against sentimentality, forcing readers to confront the price of “limited” war when the underlying aim is unconditional victory.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by William
Add to List








