"We absolutely believed in Heaven and Hell, Purgatory, and even Limbo. I mean, they were actually closer to us than Australia or Canada, that they were real places"
About this Quote
Heaven and Hell aren not metaphors here; theyre coordinates. McGahern drops you into an Ireland where the afterlife sits on the same mental map as the next county, while Australia and Canada (real destinations for emigrants) feel abstract, almost fictional. The line is funny in its bluntness, but the humor has teeth: it exposes how a culture can treat doctrine as geography, and how that reshapes what people fear, desire, and accept as inevitable.
The key move is scale. By saying these realms were "closer" than faraway countries, he isnt making a theological claim so much as an anthropological one: the Churchs narrative infrastructure outcompeted lived experience. Limbo and Purgatory are telling inclusions because theyre the bureaucratic zones of belief, the intermediate states that mirror a society obsessed with moral accounting. Even the fuzzy, later-deemphasized Limbo had more street cred than the literal world beyond the island.
Subtext: when your cosmology is that immediate, it becomes a form of social governance. If Hell is nearer than Canada, leaving carries not just economic risk but spiritual peril; staying means remaining inside a comprehensible system of punishments and permissions. McGahern, the chronicler of rural constraint and quiet revolt, captures how faith can be less about transcendence than about proximity - the stories nearest to you are the ones that get to be real.
The key move is scale. By saying these realms were "closer" than faraway countries, he isnt making a theological claim so much as an anthropological one: the Churchs narrative infrastructure outcompeted lived experience. Limbo and Purgatory are telling inclusions because theyre the bureaucratic zones of belief, the intermediate states that mirror a society obsessed with moral accounting. Even the fuzzy, later-deemphasized Limbo had more street cred than the literal world beyond the island.
Subtext: when your cosmology is that immediate, it becomes a form of social governance. If Hell is nearer than Canada, leaving carries not just economic risk but spiritual peril; staying means remaining inside a comprehensible system of punishments and permissions. McGahern, the chronicler of rural constraint and quiet revolt, captures how faith can be less about transcendence than about proximity - the stories nearest to you are the ones that get to be real.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
