Politics & Power Quote by Colin Powell

"We all hoped in 2001 that we could put in place an Afghan government under President Karzai that would be able to control the country, make sure al-Qaeda didn't come back, and make sure the Taliban wasn't resurging. It didn't work out"

Colin Powell, Statesman

About this Quote

Powell’s blunt coda - “It didn’t work out” - is doing more than summarizing a failed policy. It’s an intentionally flattened epitaph for an era of American confidence that treated state-building as a solvable engineering problem: install a central government, empower a respectable partner (Karzai), deny space to terrorists, suppress the insurgency. The sentence compresses years of contested choices into a single, almost managerial verdict, a rhetorical move that both owns the outcome and drains it of heat.

The context matters: 2001 wasn’t just a date, it was a mandate. After 9/11, the U.S. needed a narrative of control - not only over al-Qaeda, but over the conditions that supposedly produced it. Karzai became the embodiment of that story: a leader who could translate American aims into Afghan legitimacy. Powell frames this as “we all hoped,” spreading responsibility across a bipartisan, institutional consensus. That “we” is also a shield: the failure belongs to the system, not a lone decision-maker.

Subtext: the objectives were in tension from the start. “Control the country” implies a strong central state in a place with deep regional power structures. “Make sure al-Qaeda didn’t come back” hints at a narrow counterterrorism goal, while “make sure the Taliban wasn’t resurging” admits the political reality of an enemy that wasn’t simply a terrorist network but a durable insurgency with local roots and external sanctuaries. Powell’s choice to end on understatement signals a statesman’s preference for restraint - a quiet acknowledgement that the ambition exceeded the leverage.

Quote Details

Topic	War
Source	Help us find the source
Cite

More Quotes by Colin Add to List

About the Author

Colin Powell

Colin Powell (born April 5, 1937) is a Statesman from USA.

48 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"As the country now turns a new leaf, our ambition is to give hope to each and every Afghan"

Hamid Karzai, Statesman

Hamid Karzai

"Now, al Qaeda's on the run. Afghanistan is no longer a base of operations. The Afghan government is a friendly government that is trying to bring democracy to its people"

Condoleezza Rice, Statesman

Condoleezza Rice

"We can't afford to see Afghanistan roll backwards into a failed state that could become a base from which terrorist campaigns can be launched anywhere in the world"

Liam Fox, Politician

"I think we need to just be very clear about what we're trying to do in Afghanistan. Frankly, we're not trying to create the perfect democracy. We're never going to create some ideal society. We are simply there for our own national security"

David Cameron, Politician

"To leave Afghanistan as a playground for terrorists and adventurers was simply not possible anymore"

Lakhdar Brahimi, Diplomat

Lakhdar Brahimi

"In fact, if you look upon the situation today, there is great division in the world and we have failed to capitalize on that unity to finish the job in Afghanistan and against al Qaeda"

Chris Van Hollen, Politician

"I just think it would be unrealistic to suggest we're going to eliminate every last domestic insurgent in Afghanistan. Certainly, the history of the country would indicate that's not a very realistic objective, and I think we have to have realistic objectives"

Stephen Harper, Politician

Stephen Harper

"Trying to rebuild Afghanistan on the cheap has left the country in the hands of warlords and an impotent Northern Alliance puppet regime that runs Kabul and nothing else"

Ted Rall, Cartoonist

"I suggested that we had experience in helping other countries build their military forces, and we would be willing and happy to do the same for Afghanistan, together with the United States"

Bulent Ecevit, Politician

"But if too many countries, as has been the case, interfere too much in the internal affairs, the political situation of Afghanistan, then, of course, we can't hope satisfactory results"

Bulent Ecevit, Politician

"You would have thought that after 9/11, the president would have finished the job in Afghanistan, and kept the focus on capturing Bin Laden and his al-Qaeda deputies, but he and his team gave top priority to their original plan to invade Iraq"

Bill Nelson, Politician

"There's no doubt that it's still a dangerous place, Afghanistan. The fortunate thing is that the United States was helping to provide security for Chairman Karzai. And it shows that the United States is committed to that regime"

Condoleezza Rice, Statesman

Condoleezza Rice

"Once the Afghan people vote and they choose their President with direct, secret ballot from all over the country, there will be a lot of difference in this country and a lot of legitimate power to flow with implementation"

Hamid Karzai, Statesman

Hamid Karzai

"No one talked about the fact that in this year under the Obama administration you've seen the highest casualties in Afghanistan. And the fact that it took him almost 90 days to figure out what his strategy is going to be was absolutely appalling"

Allen West, Politician

"We didn't do anything wrong, but among the lessons learned, given the magnitude of the problems we now face in Afghanistan, a major U.S. force on the ground would convince the world we were in for the long-haul recovery of a country devastated by 21 years of warfare"

Alexander Haig, Public Servant

"There is a difference between a military mission and the aspiration for the long-term plans for the country. What we want is a stable enough Afghanistan, able to look after its own security so we can leave without the fear of it imploding... But let's be clear - it's not going to be perfect"

Liam Fox, Politician

"We had a couple of minor coups that made a big difference. We snared away from a competitor a correspondent already on the ground in Afghanistan. That was an enormous help to us, because there we were"

Brit Hume, Journalist

"We've got to see a state where the Afghan government can handle its own day-to-day security"

Stephen Harper, Politician

Stephen Harper

"After September 11, when the United States took action to overthrow the Taliban, our interests and Iran's aligned, and we were able to coordinate quietly but effectively"

Earl Blumenauer, Politician

"We can stay in Afghanistan and stabilize the situation, or we can get out and win, or we can get out and lose"

Dinesh D'Souza, Author