Skip to main content

Time & Perspective Quote by Anatole Broyard

"We are all tourists in history, and irony is what we win in wars"

About this Quote

History, in Broyard's line, isn’t a home you build in; it’s a place you pass through with a camera and a map you barely understand. Calling us "tourists" is a quiet insult disguised as a shrug. Tourists consume sites, miss the language, misread the customs, then leave with souvenirs that feel like understanding. That’s his dig at the way individuals and nations narrate their own eras: we experience events up close but comprehend them at a distance, once the brochure has been printed.

The second clause lands like a bitter punchline. Wars are sold as moral clarifications, as engines of meaning and victory. Broyard says the only reliable "winnings" are irony: unintended consequences, reversed roles, the gap between what leaders promise and what history records. Irony is the historian’s currency because it’s what remains after the banners rot - the tragicomic mismatch between intention and outcome.

As a critic, Broyard is also winking at his own trade. Criticism is tourism with better sentences: you enter a world (a novel, a moment, a public tragedy), point at what others overlook, and admit you weren’t built for permanence there. The subtext is humility with teeth. People crave narrative mastery, especially after catastrophe; Broyard offers a colder comfort. You don’t get to own history, and if you insist on calling violence a path to meaning, history will answer by making you look foolish.

Quote Details

TopicWar
SourceHelp us find the source
More Quotes by Anatole Add to List
We are all tourists in history, and irony is what we win in wars
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Anatole Broyard (July 19, 1920 - October 11, 1990) was a Critic from USA.

12 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Saul Bellow, Novelist
Saul Bellow