"We are beaten, we will make no bones about it; but we are not too badly beaten still to fight"
About this Quote
Defeat is admitted without theatrics, then immediately weaponized. Larkin’s line has the blunt candor of a man speaking to people who can smell spin a mile away: “we will make no bones about it” refuses the comforting lie that everything is fine. That refusal matters. Movements don’t just collapse from losses; they collapse when leaders start varnishing reality and the rank-and-file stop believing their own story. Larkin is stabilizing morale by stripping away false morale.
The pivot is the real craft: “but” doesn’t negate the loss, it reframes it as survivable. “Not too badly beaten” is calibrated understatement, a way of measuring pain without dramatizing it. He’s telling workers: yes, the bosses and the state landed blows, maybe the strike is broken, maybe the jail cells are filling. Still, the body is intact enough to swing back. The phrase “still to fight” puts agency back in the listener’s hands; it’s not a prediction, it’s a decision.
Contextually, this sounds like the cadence of early 20th-century Irish labor struggle, where setbacks were routine and power was unapologetically coercive. Larkin’s intent isn’t poetic consolation; it’s organizational triage. Admit the wound, stop the panic, keep the structure alive long enough to regroup. The subtext is almost tactical: if we can name the defeat, we can learn from it; if we can keep fighting, we can keep existing as a class force. The quote is less about bravery than continuity.
The pivot is the real craft: “but” doesn’t negate the loss, it reframes it as survivable. “Not too badly beaten” is calibrated understatement, a way of measuring pain without dramatizing it. He’s telling workers: yes, the bosses and the state landed blows, maybe the strike is broken, maybe the jail cells are filling. Still, the body is intact enough to swing back. The phrase “still to fight” puts agency back in the listener’s hands; it’s not a prediction, it’s a decision.
Contextually, this sounds like the cadence of early 20th-century Irish labor struggle, where setbacks were routine and power was unapologetically coercive. Larkin’s intent isn’t poetic consolation; it’s organizational triage. Admit the wound, stop the panic, keep the structure alive long enough to regroup. The subtext is almost tactical: if we can name the defeat, we can learn from it; if we can keep fighting, we can keep existing as a class force. The quote is less about bravery than continuity.
Quote Details
| Topic | Never Give Up |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by James
Add to List









