"We are born believing. A man bears beliefs as a tree bears apples"
About this Quote
Emerson makes belief sound less like a choice and more like a biological fact: you arrive in the world credulous, and convictions ripen on you the way fruit does on a tree. That metaphor is doing stealthy cultural work. It demotes belief from the heroic realm of reasoned principle to the ordinary realm of growth, season, and habit. Apples aren not arguments; they are outcomes of soil, weather, and species. By analogy, Emerson suggests that what we call our "considered views" are often the predictable yield of temperament, upbringing, and the invisible climate of a culture.
The line also carries a provocative subtext for an America increasingly enchanted with institutions, doctrines, and inherited authority. Emerson, the Transcendentalist, is always tugging the reader away from secondhand faith and toward self-reliance. Yet he is too honest to pretend the mind begins as a blank, sovereign judge. We are born believing: the first posture of consciousness is trust, not skepticism. That admission undercuts Enlightenment swagger while sharpening his real point: because beliefs sprout naturally, they must be tended. A tree that bears apples will bear them whether they are sweet or wormy.
Context matters. Writing in the 19th century, Emerson watched a young nation professionalize religion and politics into systems that demanded loyalty. His image of belief as organic growth implies both vulnerability and responsibility: you cannot avoid having beliefs, but you can prune, graft, and cultivate them. The wit is quiet, almost pastoral, but the implication is sharp: the most dangerous beliefs are the ones we treat as deliberate conclusions when they are really just our season's crop.
The line also carries a provocative subtext for an America increasingly enchanted with institutions, doctrines, and inherited authority. Emerson, the Transcendentalist, is always tugging the reader away from secondhand faith and toward self-reliance. Yet he is too honest to pretend the mind begins as a blank, sovereign judge. We are born believing: the first posture of consciousness is trust, not skepticism. That admission undercuts Enlightenment swagger while sharpening his real point: because beliefs sprout naturally, they must be tended. A tree that bears apples will bear them whether they are sweet or wormy.
Context matters. Writing in the 19th century, Emerson watched a young nation professionalize religion and politics into systems that demanded loyalty. His image of belief as organic growth implies both vulnerability and responsibility: you cannot avoid having beliefs, but you can prune, graft, and cultivate them. The wit is quiet, almost pastoral, but the implication is sharp: the most dangerous beliefs are the ones we treat as deliberate conclusions when they are really just our season's crop.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List










