"We are certainly in a common class with the beasts; every action of animal life is concerned with seeking bodily pleasure and avoiding pain"
About this Quote
Augustine doesn’t flatter human exceptionalism here; he cuts it down to size. The line’s bite comes from its unembarrassed biological realism: strip away our rhetoric, he suggests, and you’ll find the same engine that drives livestock and lions - pleasure sought, pain dodged. For a Christian bishop, that’s not a concession to materialism so much as a setup for indictment. He’s naming the baseline with clinical candor so he can argue that a life organized around the baseline is, by definition, a diminished one.
The intent is pastoral and polemical at once. Augustine is trying to dislodge the reader from the easy confidence that “following nature” is automatically good. If “nature” means the animal circuitry of appetite and aversion, then treating desire as your compass doesn’t liberate you; it chains you. The subtext is his larger anthropology: humans are a split creature, capable of God and trapped in habit. We share the beasts’ impulses, but we also have the unnerving ability to reflect on them, rationalize them, and build whole cultures that dignify them.
Context matters: Augustine is writing against both pagan moral self-sufficiency and any comfy Christian moralism that underestimates concupiscence - disordered desire - after the Fall. He speaks as someone who knows the seductions he’s diagnosing. The austerity of the sentence is the point: it refuses romantic language so the reader can’t hide behind it. He’s forcing the question that follows: if pleasure and pain are the whole map, what makes a human life anything more than well-managed animal life?
The intent is pastoral and polemical at once. Augustine is trying to dislodge the reader from the easy confidence that “following nature” is automatically good. If “nature” means the animal circuitry of appetite and aversion, then treating desire as your compass doesn’t liberate you; it chains you. The subtext is his larger anthropology: humans are a split creature, capable of God and trapped in habit. We share the beasts’ impulses, but we also have the unnerving ability to reflect on them, rationalize them, and build whole cultures that dignify them.
Context matters: Augustine is writing against both pagan moral self-sufficiency and any comfy Christian moralism that underestimates concupiscence - disordered desire - after the Fall. He speaks as someone who knows the seductions he’s diagnosing. The austerity of the sentence is the point: it refuses romantic language so the reader can’t hide behind it. He’s forcing the question that follows: if pleasure and pain are the whole map, what makes a human life anything more than well-managed animal life?
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Saint
Add to List
