"We are embedded in a biological world and related to the organisms around us"
About this Quote
Gilbert’s line has the quiet force of a scientist trying to smuggle humility back into a culture addicted to human exceptionalism. “Embedded” is the tell: it’s not the softer “connected to,” which can sound like a nature-poster sentiment. Embedded means situated, constrained, and shaped by the living systems we like to treat as background scenery. The word flips the usual hierarchy. We’re not observers standing outside the biosphere with clipboards and godlike discretion; we’re inside the experiment.
The second clause sharpens the point by choosing “related” over “similar.” Related is evolutionary, genealogical, almost bureaucratic: kinship you can’t opt out of. It carries Darwin’s subversive implication that the distance between us and “the organisms around us” isn’t metaphysical, it’s historical. That phrasing also works politically. If other organisms are our relations, then extraction and domination start to read less like “resource management” and more like a family feud with consequences we can’t neatly externalize.
Context matters because Gilbert isn’t a poet; he’s a molecular biologist associated with the genomic turn, a period when biology increasingly revealed shared cellular machinery across species and the porousness of boundaries we once assumed were firm. The quote’s intent is partly corrective: to push back against the idea that biotechnology places humans above nature, when in reality it exposes how thoroughly we’re made of the same parts, subject to the same ecological dependencies, and vulnerable to the same systemic feedback. In a century of climate disruption and zoonotic spillover, the subtext lands as warning, not wonder.
The second clause sharpens the point by choosing “related” over “similar.” Related is evolutionary, genealogical, almost bureaucratic: kinship you can’t opt out of. It carries Darwin’s subversive implication that the distance between us and “the organisms around us” isn’t metaphysical, it’s historical. That phrasing also works politically. If other organisms are our relations, then extraction and domination start to read less like “resource management” and more like a family feud with consequences we can’t neatly externalize.
Context matters because Gilbert isn’t a poet; he’s a molecular biologist associated with the genomic turn, a period when biology increasingly revealed shared cellular machinery across species and the porousness of boundaries we once assumed were firm. The quote’s intent is partly corrective: to push back against the idea that biotechnology places humans above nature, when in reality it exposes how thoroughly we’re made of the same parts, subject to the same ecological dependencies, and vulnerable to the same systemic feedback. In a century of climate disruption and zoonotic spillover, the subtext lands as warning, not wonder.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List







