Skip to main content

Aging & Wisdom Quote by Rutherford B. Hayes

"We are in a period when old questions are settled and the new are not yet brought forward. Extreme party action, if continued in such a time, would ruin the party. Moderation is its only chance. The party out of power gains by all partisan conduct of those in power"

About this Quote

Hayes is doing the rare thing presidents almost never do in public: admitting the political weather is transitional and therefore dangerous. The line lands because it treats politics less like a holy war and more like risk management. "Old questions are settled" reads as a quiet warning against nostalgia-fueled mobilization; he's saying the last era's fights have exhausted their usefulness, so acting like they're still existential is performative. "The new are not yet brought forward" captures a familiar vacuum: when the next agenda hasn't cohered, parties compensate with spectacle, purity tests, and scorched-earth tactics.

The subtext is a plea for discipline aimed at his own side. "Extreme party action... would ruin the party" isn't moral panic; it's a practical threat assessment. Hayes is president, but he's also a partisan steward trying to prevent short-term base gratification from collapsing coalition legitimacy. The crucial word is "continued": he's not denying that hardball works in bursts, he's arguing that sustained escalation in a liminal moment burns the brand, frays institutions, and gives voters permission to defect.

Context matters. Hayes comes out of the Compromise of 1877 and the messy end of Reconstruction, an era when "settled" often meant settled by exhaustion and backroom bargains. His moderation pitch doubles as damage control: after a disputed election and amid sectional resentment, he frames restraint as survival, not virtue.

The final sentence is the dagger: those in power create the opposition's momentum. It's a cynical, accurate account of how backlash is manufactured - by overreach, by contempt, by treating governance as party theater. Hayes is selling moderation as strategy because he understands the asymmetry: incumbents own the consequences; outsiders only need a story.

Quote Details

TopicLeadership
SourceHelp us find the source
Cite

Citation Formats

APA Style (7th ed.)
Hayes, Rutherford B. (2026, January 16). We are in a period when old questions are settled and the new are not yet brought forward. Extreme party action, if continued in such a time, would ruin the party. Moderation is its only chance. The party out of power gains by all partisan conduct of those in power. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-are-in-a-period-when-old-questions-are-settled-85748/

Chicago Style
Hayes, Rutherford B. "We are in a period when old questions are settled and the new are not yet brought forward. Extreme party action, if continued in such a time, would ruin the party. Moderation is its only chance. The party out of power gains by all partisan conduct of those in power." FixQuotes. January 16, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-are-in-a-period-when-old-questions-are-settled-85748/.

MLA Style (9th ed.)
"We are in a period when old questions are settled and the new are not yet brought forward. Extreme party action, if continued in such a time, would ruin the party. Moderation is its only chance. The party out of power gains by all partisan conduct of those in power." FixQuotes, 16 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-are-in-a-period-when-old-questions-are-settled-85748/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.

More Quotes by Rutherford Add to List
Moderation is its only chance - Rutherford B Hayes Quote Analysis
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Rutherford B. Hayes (October 4, 1822 - January 17, 1893) was a President from USA.

27 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes