"We are like horses who hurt themselves as soon as they pull on their bits - and we bow our heads. We even lose consciousness of the situation, we just submit. Any re-awakening of thought is then painful"
About this Quote
The violence in Weil's image isn’t the rider’s whip; it’s the horse’s own reflex. The bit only injures once the animal pulls, and Weil’s point is merciless: the most efficient domination recruits its victims as participants. You don’t have to be constantly coerced if you can be trained to do the coercing for yourself, to learn that resistance hurts more than surrender. The bowed head is not humility. It’s an adaptation, a survival posture that gradually becomes a personality.
Her second move is darker. “We even lose consciousness of the situation” names the way oppression becomes ordinary not through propaganda alone but through exhaustion. Attention, in Weil’s moral universe, is a scarce resource; when work, fear, or social pressure consume it, thought doesn’t triumphantly “break free.” It flickers out. Submission isn’t always chosen; it’s often the numbness that follows repeated, futile attempts to pull against the bit.
Then she twists the knife: “Any re-awakening of thought is then painful.” This is psychology as political theory. To wake up is to feel the wound you’ve been living with, to recognize the contortions you’ve normalized, to see your own complicity without the comforting story that you had no agency. Weil, writing in the shadow of industrial labor, fascism, and war, isn’t offering a motivational slogan. She’s mapping a trap: systems that make lucidity hurt will reliably purchase obedience, because the cheapest peace is unconsciousness.
Her second move is darker. “We even lose consciousness of the situation” names the way oppression becomes ordinary not through propaganda alone but through exhaustion. Attention, in Weil’s moral universe, is a scarce resource; when work, fear, or social pressure consume it, thought doesn’t triumphantly “break free.” It flickers out. Submission isn’t always chosen; it’s often the numbness that follows repeated, futile attempts to pull against the bit.
Then she twists the knife: “Any re-awakening of thought is then painful.” This is psychology as political theory. To wake up is to feel the wound you’ve been living with, to recognize the contortions you’ve normalized, to see your own complicity without the comforting story that you had no agency. Weil, writing in the shadow of industrial labor, fascism, and war, isn’t offering a motivational slogan. She’s mapping a trap: systems that make lucidity hurt will reliably purchase obedience, because the cheapest peace is unconsciousness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Simone
Add to List







