"We are much beholden to Machiavel and others, that write what men do, and not what they ought to do"
About this Quote
Bacon’s line flatters the cold-eyed realist while quietly rebuking the pious frauds who pretend politics is a morality play. “Much beholden” is doing sly work: he’s not just thanking Machiavelli; he’s admitting a kind of dependence. If you want to govern, advise princes, or even understand your own age, you can’t live on sermons. You need field reports.
The intent is methodological. Bacon, the great salesman for a new way of knowing, is defending an empirical posture in political thought: start with what people actually do, then build your understanding from that stubborn data. It’s the same Bacon who attacked “idols” of the mind and urged observation over inherited authority. Here, Machiavelli becomes a patron saint of unromantic description, a writer who refuses to confuse aspiration with diagnosis.
The subtext, though, is more delicate. Bacon isn’t endorsing cynicism as a life philosophy; he’s insisting that moral ideals without behavioral truth are useless, even dangerous. Telling rulers what they “ought” to do can become a way of laundering power, masking self-interest in virtue-talk. Better to confront ambition, fear, vanity, and coercion as they operate in daylight. Only then can ethics be more than decoration.
Context matters: early 17th-century England is wrestling with statecraft, religion, and consolidating authority; Bacon himself was a court insider who rose and fell on the machinery he studied. The line reads like the credo of a man who learned that lofty counsel is cheap, and accurate description is costly.
The intent is methodological. Bacon, the great salesman for a new way of knowing, is defending an empirical posture in political thought: start with what people actually do, then build your understanding from that stubborn data. It’s the same Bacon who attacked “idols” of the mind and urged observation over inherited authority. Here, Machiavelli becomes a patron saint of unromantic description, a writer who refuses to confuse aspiration with diagnosis.
The subtext, though, is more delicate. Bacon isn’t endorsing cynicism as a life philosophy; he’s insisting that moral ideals without behavioral truth are useless, even dangerous. Telling rulers what they “ought” to do can become a way of laundering power, masking self-interest in virtue-talk. Better to confront ambition, fear, vanity, and coercion as they operate in daylight. Only then can ethics be more than decoration.
Context matters: early 17th-century England is wrestling with statecraft, religion, and consolidating authority; Bacon himself was a court insider who rose and fell on the machinery he studied. The line reads like the credo of a man who learned that lofty counsel is cheap, and accurate description is costly.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Francis
Add to List
