"We are not born all at once, but by bits. The body first, and the spirit later; and the birth and growth of the spirit, in those who are attentive to their own inner life, are slow and exceedingly painful"
About this Quote
Antin rejects the tidy myth of instantaneous selfhood. “Not born all at once, but by bits” is a deliberate rebuke to the sentimental conversion story: the idea that identity arrives fully formed, that a person can simply decide who they are and be done with it. She splits development into two timelines - body first, spirit later - not to spiritualize the self, but to insist that inner maturity is an earned, uneven process, shaped by friction.
The subtext is disciplinary. Antin isn’t praising suffering for its own sake; she’s warning that the “spirit” doesn’t grow on slogans, heritage, or borrowed certainty. It grows in the slow labor of attention: “those who are attentive to their own inner life.” That phrase quietly draws a line between people who merely live and people who examine their living, a modern-sounding ethic of self-scrutiny that can feel empowering and accusatory at once. If the work is optional, the cost is too.
Context matters: Antin’s era is thick with arguments about assimilation, citizenship, women’s roles, and the moral narrative of “becoming American.” As an activist voice in the early 20th century, she’s also pushing back against the period’s hunger for clean categories - immigrant/native, civilized/backward, proper/improper. Her point is that the most consequential border runs inside a person, and crossing it is “exceedingly painful.” The line lands because it dignifies that pain without romanticizing it, framing growth as both an interior politics and a private ordeal.
The subtext is disciplinary. Antin isn’t praising suffering for its own sake; she’s warning that the “spirit” doesn’t grow on slogans, heritage, or borrowed certainty. It grows in the slow labor of attention: “those who are attentive to their own inner life.” That phrase quietly draws a line between people who merely live and people who examine their living, a modern-sounding ethic of self-scrutiny that can feel empowering and accusatory at once. If the work is optional, the cost is too.
Context matters: Antin’s era is thick with arguments about assimilation, citizenship, women’s roles, and the moral narrative of “becoming American.” As an activist voice in the early 20th century, she’s also pushing back against the period’s hunger for clean categories - immigrant/native, civilized/backward, proper/improper. Her point is that the most consequential border runs inside a person, and crossing it is “exceedingly painful.” The line lands because it dignifies that pain without romanticizing it, framing growth as both an interior politics and a private ordeal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Improvement |
|---|
More Quotes by Mary
Add to List
