"We are responsible for actions performed in response to circumstances for which we are not responsible"
About this Quote
A neat ethical trap is hiding in Massie’s calm prose: he splits the world into what happens to us and what we do about it, then refuses to let the first half excuse the second. The sentence is built like a legal brief, repeating “responsible” twice to tighten the noose. It concedes the obvious - we don’t choose our parents, our era, our injuries, our economic weather - then pivots to the uncomfortable: we still own our replies. The effect is bracing because it denies the two most popular modern alibis at once: fatalism (“the system made me”) and self-mythology (“I’m just a product of my trauma”).
Massie’s intent feels less like moral grandstanding than a corrective to a culture addicted to explanation-as-exoneration. The subtext is that circumstances matter profoundly, but they don’t get the final vote. If you lash out, betray, capitulate, or harden into cruelty, you can map the causes without laundering the consequence. It’s a line that respects complexity while insisting on agency - not the glossy “choose happiness” kind, but the harder kind: choosing restraint, courage, or decency when the deck is stacked.
Contextually, Massie is a Scottish writer steeped in history and classical biography, where lives are shaped by forces larger than any individual - wars, class, state power - yet judged by the decisions made inside those constraints. The quote reads like a historian’s ethic turned inward: you can’t control the storm, but you’re still accountable for what you do at the helm.
Massie’s intent feels less like moral grandstanding than a corrective to a culture addicted to explanation-as-exoneration. The subtext is that circumstances matter profoundly, but they don’t get the final vote. If you lash out, betray, capitulate, or harden into cruelty, you can map the causes without laundering the consequence. It’s a line that respects complexity while insisting on agency - not the glossy “choose happiness” kind, but the harder kind: choosing restraint, courage, or decency when the deck is stacked.
Contextually, Massie is a Scottish writer steeped in history and classical biography, where lives are shaped by forces larger than any individual - wars, class, state power - yet judged by the decisions made inside those constraints. The quote reads like a historian’s ethic turned inward: you can’t control the storm, but you’re still accountable for what you do at the helm.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Allan
Add to List
