"We are tainted by modern philosophy which has taught us that all is good, whereas evil has polluted everything and in a very real sense all is evil, since nothing is in its proper place"
About this Quote
De Maistre’s line doesn’t just reject optimism; it treats optimism as a moral anesthetic. “Modern philosophy” is his catch-all villain, less a syllabus than a cultural regime: Enlightenment confidence, secular politics, the idea that reason can tidy up a messy world. He frames that worldview as “taint,” a contamination that flatters people into believing “all is good,” as if declaring goodness can make it so.
The bite is in the inversion. He doesn’t claim evil is merely present; he claims it has “polluted everything,” so thoroughly that “all is evil” in the sense of disorder. That last clause - “nothing is in its proper place” - gives away the deeper agenda. Evil, for de Maistre, isn’t only wicked acts; it’s cosmic misalignment. A world without its ordained hierarchy (throne, altar, inherited authority) isn’t neutral or improvable. It’s a world out of joint, where even reforms become symptoms.
Context matters: de Maistre is writing in the long shadow of the French Revolution, a trauma that turned “progress” into a blood-soaked word for conservatives who watched institutions collapse and violence masquerade as virtue. The intent is polemical and strategic: delegitimize modernity by accusing it of category error, of calling good what is actually decay.
Subtextually, it’s also a demand for re-sacralization. If evil is structural, the cure can’t be debate or policy tweaks; it must be repentance, authority, and restoration. The sentence works because it turns metaphysics into political judgment: not “things are bad,” but “reality has been rearranged, and your philosophy is the accomplice.”
The bite is in the inversion. He doesn’t claim evil is merely present; he claims it has “polluted everything,” so thoroughly that “all is evil” in the sense of disorder. That last clause - “nothing is in its proper place” - gives away the deeper agenda. Evil, for de Maistre, isn’t only wicked acts; it’s cosmic misalignment. A world without its ordained hierarchy (throne, altar, inherited authority) isn’t neutral or improvable. It’s a world out of joint, where even reforms become symptoms.
Context matters: de Maistre is writing in the long shadow of the French Revolution, a trauma that turned “progress” into a blood-soaked word for conservatives who watched institutions collapse and violence masquerade as virtue. The intent is polemical and strategic: delegitimize modernity by accusing it of category error, of calling good what is actually decay.
Subtextually, it’s also a demand for re-sacralization. If evil is structural, the cure can’t be debate or policy tweaks; it must be repentance, authority, and restoration. The sentence works because it turns metaphysics into political judgment: not “things are bad,” but “reality has been rearranged, and your philosophy is the accomplice.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Joseph
Add to List






