"We, as a country, have not seen a significant change in immigration policy in nearly two decades, even though all Americans agree that current immigration policy is outdated and malfunctioning"
About this Quote
The most deliberate move is his invocation of consensus: "all Americans agree". It's less a literal claim than a pressure tactic. Grijalva is trying to disarm the standard excuse for inaction ("it's too divisive") by asserting a baseline unity around diagnosis, even if there's no unity on treatment. The subtext is pointed: if we can agree it's "outdated and malfunctioning", then Congress isn't stuck; it's choosing to be stuck. That shifts blame from the border, immigrants, or courts to lawmakers and the incentives that reward gridlock.
Calling the policy "malfunctioning" also recodes a moral and cultural debate as a technical breakdown. "Outdated" implies mismatch with contemporary labor markets, family structures, and humanitarian obligations; "malfunctioning" suggests unintended consequences - backlogs, irregular crossings, employer dependence on gray labor - that a competent legislature would not tolerate in any other system.
Contextually, this is Grijalva speaking from within the long post-1986 era where enforcement expanded, reform stalled, and executive actions filled the vacuum. The line isn't just a plea for reform; it's a rebuke of a country that has normalized dysfunction as political strategy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: Congressional Record: Border Protection, Antiterrorism, a... (Raul Grijalva, 2005)
Evidence:
We, as a country, have not seen a significant change in immigration policy in nearly two decades, even though all Americans agree that current immigration policy is outdated and malfunctioning. (Congressional Record (Daily Ed.), Vol. 151, No. 163, p. E2595 (Extensions of Remarks)). This sentence appears in Rep. Raúl M. Grijalva’s remarks opposing H.R. 4437. Congress.gov shows it under the Congressional Record for the Extensions of Remarks section dated December 17, 2005 (the speech itself is headed Friday, December 16, 2005). This is a primary-source government transcript, and it is the earliest primary instance I found for the exact wording. |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Grijalva, Raul. (2026, February 13). We, as a country, have not seen a significant change in immigration policy in nearly two decades, even though all Americans agree that current immigration policy is outdated and malfunctioning. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-as-a-country-have-not-seen-a-significant-163740/
Chicago Style
Grijalva, Raul. "We, as a country, have not seen a significant change in immigration policy in nearly two decades, even though all Americans agree that current immigration policy is outdated and malfunctioning." FixQuotes. February 13, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-as-a-country-have-not-seen-a-significant-163740/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"We, as a country, have not seen a significant change in immigration policy in nearly two decades, even though all Americans agree that current immigration policy is outdated and malfunctioning." FixQuotes, 13 Feb. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/we-as-a-country-have-not-seen-a-significant-163740/. Accessed 27 Mar. 2026.
