"We believe that civilization has been created under the pressure of the exigencies of life at the cost of satisfaction of the instincts"
About this Quote
Civilization, Freud is saying, isn’t an inspired leap forward so much as a negotiated settlement under duress. The key move is his pairing of “pressure” and “cost”: culture isn’t built because humans naturally prefer art museums to appetite, but because life forces us into compromise. Hunger, scarcity, vulnerability, rivalry, disease - the “exigencies” that make cooperation non-optional - demand rules. Those rules, in turn, demand self-denial. The sentence quietly reframes “progress” as a trade: security and order purchased with the throttling of instinct.
The intent sits squarely in Freud’s broader argument (most famously in Civilization and Its Discontents) that repression is not a side effect of modernity; it is the mechanism of civilization itself. The subtext is almost prosecutorial toward feel-good narratives about refinement. If we’re proud of our institutions, Freud wants us to notice what they’re made of: deferred gratification, redirected aggression, policed sexuality, disciplined desire. Civilization isn’t the opposite of the animal; it’s the animal with a leash, and the leash rubs.
He also slips in a diagnosis of modern malaise. If society is structurally dependent on curbing instinct, dissatisfaction isn’t a personal failure but a predictable byproduct. That makes the line bracingly contemporary: it anticipates how “well-adjusted” can feel like “well-managed,” how comfort can coexist with anxiety, how moral codes can function as both protection and punishment. Freud’s cynicism is clinical, not performative: the bargain works, but no one gets it for free.
The intent sits squarely in Freud’s broader argument (most famously in Civilization and Its Discontents) that repression is not a side effect of modernity; it is the mechanism of civilization itself. The subtext is almost prosecutorial toward feel-good narratives about refinement. If we’re proud of our institutions, Freud wants us to notice what they’re made of: deferred gratification, redirected aggression, policed sexuality, disciplined desire. Civilization isn’t the opposite of the animal; it’s the animal with a leash, and the leash rubs.
He also slips in a diagnosis of modern malaise. If society is structurally dependent on curbing instinct, dissatisfaction isn’t a personal failure but a predictable byproduct. That makes the line bracingly contemporary: it anticipates how “well-adjusted” can feel like “well-managed,” how comfort can coexist with anxiety, how moral codes can function as both protection and punishment. Freud’s cynicism is clinical, not performative: the bargain works, but no one gets it for free.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Sigmund
Add to List







