"We can do without butter, but, despite all our love of peace, not without arms. One cannot shoot with butter, but with guns"
About this Quote
Scarcity becomes a sales pitch: Goebbels turns deprivation into virtue and militarism into common sense. “We can do without butter” is domestic shorthand for comfort, pleasure, the small proof that life is improving. He names it only to demote it. Then comes the pivot: “despite all our love of peace” - a performative aside meant to launder aggression as reluctant necessity. The line doesn’t argue with evidence; it recruits with inevitability.
The genius and the poison are in the kitchen-table logic. “One cannot shoot with butter” is a sneering little syllogism that pretends to be apolitical practicality. It translates grand strategy into a simple household contrast: food versus guns, softness versus hardness, indulgence versus survival. Once you accept the frame, disagreement sounds childish: are you really choosing dairy over security? That’s the trap. By narrowing the options, he erases the third category - diplomacy, restraint, the possibility that “arms” are not protection but preparation.
Historically, this is the Nazi “guns before butter” formula in its most digestible form, aimed at normalizing rearmament and rationing while Germany steered toward conquest. The subtext is disciplinary: the citizen’s role is to endure and to comply, to rebrand hunger as patriotic seriousness. Goebbels isn’t just justifying policy; he’s manufacturing consent by making militarization feel like the only adult response to a dangerous world he and his regime were actively engineering.
The genius and the poison are in the kitchen-table logic. “One cannot shoot with butter” is a sneering little syllogism that pretends to be apolitical practicality. It translates grand strategy into a simple household contrast: food versus guns, softness versus hardness, indulgence versus survival. Once you accept the frame, disagreement sounds childish: are you really choosing dairy over security? That’s the trap. By narrowing the options, he erases the third category - diplomacy, restraint, the possibility that “arms” are not protection but preparation.
Historically, this is the Nazi “guns before butter” formula in its most digestible form, aimed at normalizing rearmament and rationing while Germany steered toward conquest. The subtext is disciplinary: the citizen’s role is to endure and to comply, to rebrand hunger as patriotic seriousness. Goebbels isn’t just justifying policy; he’s manufacturing consent by making militarization feel like the only adult response to a dangerous world he and his regime were actively engineering.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Joseph
Add to List






