"We can no longer tolerate losing one more innocent child or putting one more firefighter at risk in a fire that could have been prevented at the cost of pennies by making a couple simple changes to the construction of a cigarette"
About this Quote
Markey’s line is built like an indictment: not of smokers, but of an industry and a regulatory culture that treats predictable deaths as background noise. The rhetorical trick is the pairing of two “innocents” we’re not supposed to argue about: children (collateral victims of household fires) and firefighters (public servants literally paid to walk into consequences other people could have avoided). By placing them side by side, he collapses the usual blame narrative around cigarettes. This isn’t about personal choice; it’s about product design.
The phrase “no longer tolerate” signals a shift from tragedy to negligence. Toleration implies we’ve been complicit, accepting a steady drip of preventable fires as the price of doing business. Markey’s real target is the gap between available technology and political will. “Pennies” is doing heavy work: it’s not a cost-benefit analysis, it’s a moral taunt. If the fix is that cheap, then every delay starts to look like a choice to preserve profits over lives.
“Simple changes to the construction” points to the long fight over “fire-safe” or reduced-ignition cigarettes, which can be engineered to self-extinguish. Markey frames regulation as basic consumer safety, akin to seatbelts or childproof caps, while preempting industry talking points about complexity, freedom, or economic burden.
Subtext: if we accept a product that can be made less lethal but isn’t, we’re not just tolerating risk - we’re subsidizing it with funerals, burn units, and line-of-duty deaths.
The phrase “no longer tolerate” signals a shift from tragedy to negligence. Toleration implies we’ve been complicit, accepting a steady drip of preventable fires as the price of doing business. Markey’s real target is the gap between available technology and political will. “Pennies” is doing heavy work: it’s not a cost-benefit analysis, it’s a moral taunt. If the fix is that cheap, then every delay starts to look like a choice to preserve profits over lives.
“Simple changes to the construction” points to the long fight over “fire-safe” or reduced-ignition cigarettes, which can be engineered to self-extinguish. Markey frames regulation as basic consumer safety, akin to seatbelts or childproof caps, while preempting industry talking points about complexity, freedom, or economic burden.
Subtext: if we accept a product that can be made less lethal but isn’t, we’re not just tolerating risk - we’re subsidizing it with funerals, burn units, and line-of-duty deaths.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Ed
Add to List
