"We can sit around and go, okay, is there really a plan, does somebody really know what's happening, is it all planned out, because sometimes it just seems too remarkable to me the things that have happened to me"
About this Quote
Anxiety, dressed up as wonder, is doing most of the work here. MacDowell isn’t pitching a tidy faith in destiny so much as narrating the specific kind of disbelief that follows a life in entertainment: your career looks accidental even when it’s the product of grinding labor, lucky timing, and other people’s decisions. The question about “a plan” isn’t really philosophical; it’s the human attempt to domesticate chaos by imagining a storyboard.
What makes the line land is its conversational circling. “We can sit around and go” signals the low-stakes ritual of post-mortem meaning-making, the way people replay their own biographies like a highlight reel, looking for a hidden director. Then she toggles between skepticism (“is there really a plan”) and awe (“too remarkable to me”), capturing the emotional whiplash of sudden success: you know the industry is messy, but your own plot points feel improbably cinematic.
The subtext is gratitude with a protective edge. Calling the events “remarkable” lets her acknowledge luck without sounding self-congratulatory. It’s also a subtle refusal of the “mastermind” myth that celebrity culture loves: the idea that stars are strategic geniuses executing long arcs. In MacDowell’s version, the mystery is the point. Her phrasing invites the listener into a shared, slightly stunned intimacy: if it feels unreal to her, maybe we’re allowed to admit our lives don’t fully add up either.
What makes the line land is its conversational circling. “We can sit around and go” signals the low-stakes ritual of post-mortem meaning-making, the way people replay their own biographies like a highlight reel, looking for a hidden director. Then she toggles between skepticism (“is there really a plan”) and awe (“too remarkable to me”), capturing the emotional whiplash of sudden success: you know the industry is messy, but your own plot points feel improbably cinematic.
The subtext is gratitude with a protective edge. Calling the events “remarkable” lets her acknowledge luck without sounding self-congratulatory. It’s also a subtle refusal of the “mastermind” myth that celebrity culture loves: the idea that stars are strategic geniuses executing long arcs. In MacDowell’s version, the mystery is the point. Her phrasing invites the listener into a shared, slightly stunned intimacy: if it feels unreal to her, maybe we’re allowed to admit our lives don’t fully add up either.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Andie
Add to List


