"We Canadians are not given as a people to great patriotic displays"
About this Quote
Canadians rarely need to shout their nationhood because the country’s civic brand is built on understatement. Kim Campbell’s line turns that stereotype into a political instrument: a quiet compliment that doubles as a warning against imported theatrics. Coming from a statesman, it’s less folksy observation than strategic framing. If your electorate prides itself on restraint, then anyone trying to whip up flag-waving fervor can be cast as unserious, Americanized, or opportunistic.
The intent is to normalize a low-decibel patriotism: pride expressed through institutions, social peace, and competence rather than spectacle. Campbell’s phrasing, “not given... to great displays,” is doing cultural boundary work. It implies a national character defined by self-control, even suspicion of performative emotion. That’s a tidy rhetorical move because it lets politicians claim the moral high ground without needing to produce stirring poetry or martial imagery. You can govern as an administrator and still sound patriotic.
The subtext also carries a soft rebuke to audiences themselves: if you’re craving parades and chest-thumping, you might be craving the wrong country. It’s a pre-emptive defense against the criticism that Canada lacks passion or identity. Campbell flips the script: the absence of spectacle becomes the proof of maturity.
Context matters. Campbell governed briefly in the early 1990s, when constitutional fights, Quebec nationalism, and North American cultural gravity raised anxieties about what Canada even was. In that climate, defining Canadian patriotism as modest wasn’t just descriptive; it was a way to keep the federation emotionally legible without lighting a match.
The intent is to normalize a low-decibel patriotism: pride expressed through institutions, social peace, and competence rather than spectacle. Campbell’s phrasing, “not given... to great displays,” is doing cultural boundary work. It implies a national character defined by self-control, even suspicion of performative emotion. That’s a tidy rhetorical move because it lets politicians claim the moral high ground without needing to produce stirring poetry or martial imagery. You can govern as an administrator and still sound patriotic.
The subtext also carries a soft rebuke to audiences themselves: if you’re craving parades and chest-thumping, you might be craving the wrong country. It’s a pre-emptive defense against the criticism that Canada lacks passion or identity. Campbell flips the script: the absence of spectacle becomes the proof of maturity.
Context matters. Campbell governed briefly in the early 1990s, when constitutional fights, Quebec nationalism, and North American cultural gravity raised anxieties about what Canada even was. In that climate, defining Canadian patriotism as modest wasn’t just descriptive; it was a way to keep the federation emotionally legible without lighting a match.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|
More Quotes by Kim
Add to List
