"We cannot command Nature except by obeying her"
About this Quote
Control, Bacon suggests, is a kind of surrender. "We cannot command Nature except by obeying her" sounds like a paradox until you remember who’s talking: the early-modern evangelist for a new, instrument-driven science, writing at the moment Europe was trading medieval authority for experimental method. Bacon isn’t praising pastoral humility. He’s selling a program.
The line’s intent is tactical: it reframes obedience - a word soaked in religious and monarchical overtones - as the engine of power. Nature is not a capricious deity to be appeased with doctrine; she’s a lawful system. If you want mastery (better crops, stronger ships, reliable medicines), you don’t browbeat the world with metaphysics. You submit to constraints: measurement, repetition, error correction, the slow discipline of observation. Obedience here means alignment with reality’s rules, not moral virtue.
The subtext is a quiet attack on scholasticism and armchair certainty. Bacon is arguing that knowledge worth having is knowledge that works, and that it works only when it’s earned by deference to evidence. There’s also an imperial accent: "command" carries the swagger of an age of exploration and extraction. Bacon’s bargain is seductive - accept Nature’s terms and she becomes legible, usable, profitable.
Read now, the line cuts two ways. It underwrites modern technological confidence, but it also contains its own warning: ignore ecological feedback, physical limits, biological complexity, and Nature stops being commanded and starts issuing consequences. The obedience Bacon prescribes isn’t meekness; it’s realism with ambitions.
The line’s intent is tactical: it reframes obedience - a word soaked in religious and monarchical overtones - as the engine of power. Nature is not a capricious deity to be appeased with doctrine; she’s a lawful system. If you want mastery (better crops, stronger ships, reliable medicines), you don’t browbeat the world with metaphysics. You submit to constraints: measurement, repetition, error correction, the slow discipline of observation. Obedience here means alignment with reality’s rules, not moral virtue.
The subtext is a quiet attack on scholasticism and armchair certainty. Bacon is arguing that knowledge worth having is knowledge that works, and that it works only when it’s earned by deference to evidence. There’s also an imperial accent: "command" carries the swagger of an age of exploration and extraction. Bacon’s bargain is seductive - accept Nature’s terms and she becomes legible, usable, profitable.
Read now, the line cuts two ways. It underwrites modern technological confidence, but it also contains its own warning: ignore ecological feedback, physical limits, biological complexity, and Nature stops being commanded and starts issuing consequences. The obedience Bacon prescribes isn’t meekness; it’s realism with ambitions.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Francis Bacon, Novum Organum (1620). Commonly cited source for the aphorism 'We cannot command Nature except by obeying her.' |
More Quotes by Francis
Add to List
