"We cast a shadow on something wherever we stand"
About this Quote
Forster’s line is a quiet moral grenade: it makes “standing” - the most passive verb imaginable - into an act with consequences. The image is simple, almost childlike, but it refuses innocence. A shadow isn’t a decision; it’s physics. You don’t have to lunge, argue, or even speak to change the space around you. Just existing, occupying a place, throws darkness somewhere else.
That’s classic Forster: the liberal humanist who keeps discovering, to his discomfort, that decency isn’t clean. The subtext is accountability without melodrama. He’s not accusing you of malice; he’s denying you the fantasy of harmlessness. In a world structured by class, empire, and private power - Forster’s world, and still ours - the notion of “I’m just minding my own business” becomes a kind of self-exculpating myth. Even your neutrality blocks someone’s light.
It also works as a miniature of social life. Shadows imply proximity: you only shade what you’re near. Forster’s fiction is obsessed with what happens when people draw close across the wrong boundaries - English and Indian, rich and poor, respectable and queer - and discover that good intentions don’t prevent collateral damage. The line reads like a warning to the comfortable: your stance, your position, your refusal to move matters.
The beauty is its restraint. No villains, no sermons. Just a reminder that every place you claim has an unseen cost paid by whatever - or whoever - ends up in the shade.
That’s classic Forster: the liberal humanist who keeps discovering, to his discomfort, that decency isn’t clean. The subtext is accountability without melodrama. He’s not accusing you of malice; he’s denying you the fantasy of harmlessness. In a world structured by class, empire, and private power - Forster’s world, and still ours - the notion of “I’m just minding my own business” becomes a kind of self-exculpating myth. Even your neutrality blocks someone’s light.
It also works as a miniature of social life. Shadows imply proximity: you only shade what you’re near. Forster’s fiction is obsessed with what happens when people draw close across the wrong boundaries - English and Indian, rich and poor, respectable and queer - and discover that good intentions don’t prevent collateral damage. The line reads like a warning to the comfortable: your stance, your position, your refusal to move matters.
The beauty is its restraint. No villains, no sermons. Just a reminder that every place you claim has an unseen cost paid by whatever - or whoever - ends up in the shade.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|---|
| Source | Howards End — E. M. Forster (1910). Line from Forster's novel commonly cited: “We cast a shadow on something wherever we stand.” |
More Quotes by M. Forster
Add to List








