"We dance round in a ring and suppose, but the secret sits in the middle and knows"
About this Quote
Human beings love the comfort of motion: circling a question feels like progress even when it’s just choreography. Frost’s line is a small masterpiece of humiliating clarity. “We dance round in a ring” turns inquiry into ritual, something social and performative. Dancing implies joy, even self-congratulation; a ring implies consensus and enclosure. Then comes the quiet dagger: “and suppose.” Our theories, beliefs, and arguments aren’t knowledge so much as elegant guesses, rehearsed with the confidence of a community keeping time.
The pivot is the “secret” at the center. Frost doesn’t say the secret is hidden; it “sits.” Still, sovereign. The subtext is that truth isn’t necessarily complicated or distant. It can be right there, inert and obvious, while we expend energy orbiting it. The line “and knows” is almost insulting in its simplicity. The secret isn’t striving; it possesses what we lack. Frost assigns knowledge not to the seekers but to the thing sought, which flips the usual romantic story of the heroic mind closing in on truth.
Context matters: Frost’s work often stages rural plainness as a test of modern certainty. He writes in a voice that sounds neighborly, even homespun, then slips in philosophical pressure. Here he’s also taking a shot at intellectual fashion: argument as a kind of dance, ideas as social signals. The ring can be a seminar, a town meeting, a culture war. Frost’s intent is less to mystify than to warn: activity is not insight, and communities can turn ignorance into a coordinated performance.
The pivot is the “secret” at the center. Frost doesn’t say the secret is hidden; it “sits.” Still, sovereign. The subtext is that truth isn’t necessarily complicated or distant. It can be right there, inert and obvious, while we expend energy orbiting it. The line “and knows” is almost insulting in its simplicity. The secret isn’t striving; it possesses what we lack. Frost assigns knowledge not to the seekers but to the thing sought, which flips the usual romantic story of the heroic mind closing in on truth.
Context matters: Frost’s work often stages rural plainness as a test of modern certainty. He writes in a voice that sounds neighborly, even homespun, then slips in philosophical pressure. Here he’s also taking a shot at intellectual fashion: argument as a kind of dance, ideas as social signals. The ring can be a seminar, a town meeting, a culture war. Frost’s intent is less to mystify than to warn: activity is not insight, and communities can turn ignorance into a coordinated performance.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Unverified source: A Witness Tree (Robert Frost, 1942)
Evidence: Page 71 (poem: "The Secret Sits"). The line is the complete two-line poem "The Secret Sits" by Robert Frost. It is printed in Frost’s poetry collection A Witness Tree (first published 1942). A Christie's catalog entry for a first edition presentation copy explicitly states the poem is printed on ... Other candidates (2) Robert Frost (Robert Frost) compilation98.5% song be the same we dance round in a ring and suppose but the secret sits in the middle and knows t Literary Theory (Jonathan D. Culler, 2009) compilation95.0% ... Robert Frost : The Secret Sits We dance round in a ring and suppose , But the Secret sits in the middle and knows... |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
